Rookie discussions and when to cash

[Keeper27]

Papley over McCarthy to save 30k?

Surely Papley doesn't last more then 2 rounds? I would say McCarthy's JS is better.

this. once mcglynn is back papley will be the 1st to go.

[fanTCfool]

Papley is not even named yet, just promoted

[enzedder]

Surely Papley can't be considered. Will be lucky to play and if he is won't play many after that.

[LordSneeze]

Milera or Kennedy?

[LordSneeze]

Also swung Kerridge to Mids playing as M8, Menadue Fwd to field over Mccarthy and Tippa

[jfitty]

Milera or Kennedy?

Kennedy for mine.. Who do you have currently?

[spudaroos]

Who would you guys pick? Papley or Kommer, I know Kommer isn't going to score well but seems to have decent j/s, not sure about Papley as a scorer or his j/s.

[LordSneeze]

Milera or Kennedy?

Kennedy for mine.. Who do you have currently?

Kennedy, but I feel Milera will score maybe 5 points less and make the same amount of cash overall. . But the extra 10k can really be useful for a mid rookie.

[jfitty]

Who would you guys pick? Papley or Kommer, I know Kommer isn't going to score well but seems to have decent j/s, not sure about Papley as a scorer or his j/s.

I think we might have to pick Kommer if he's named. Papley could line up, but as others have pointed out he might not last when McGlynn comes in.

Having said that he could push out guys like Brandon Jack for a spot..

[jfitty]

Milera or Kennedy?

Kennedy for mine.. Who do you have currently?

Kennedy, but I feel Milera will score maybe 5 points less and make the same amount of cash overall. . But the extra 10k can really be useful for a mid rookie.

Milera's job security worries me.. Unless he performs they probably won't pick him, Eddie, Charlie Cameron and Troy Menzel

[TomK]

Milera or Kennedy?

Kennedy for mine.. Who do you have currently?

Kennedy, but I feel Milera will score maybe 5 points less and make the same amount of cash overall. . But the extra 10k can really be useful for a mid rookie.

Milera's job security worries me.. Unless he performs they probably won't pick him, Eddie, Charlie Cameron and Troy Menzel

Menzel won't get a game until he stops being lazy

[Bill Manspeaker]

Gresh will debut  8)

[LordSneeze]

Milera or Kennedy?

Kennedy for mine.. Who do you have currently?

Kennedy, but I feel Milera will score maybe 5 points less and make the same amount of cash overall. . But the extra 10k can really be useful for a mid rookie.

Milera's job security worries me.. Unless he performs they probably won't pick him, Eddie, Charlie Cameron and Troy Menzel

Menzel won't get a game until he stops being lazy

I have him over Menzel and Cameron. His skills, poise, pressure is all much better than them.

[TomK]

Milera or Kennedy?

Kennedy for mine.. Who do you have currently?

Kennedy, but I feel Milera will score maybe 5 points less and make the same amount of cash overall. . But the extra 10k can really be useful for a mid rookie.

Milera's job security worries me.. Unless he performs they probably won't pick him, Eddie, Charlie Cameron and Troy Menzel

Menzel won't get a game until he stops being lazy

I have him over Menzel and Cameron. His skills, poise, pressure is all much better than them.

I would still have Cameron over Milera, I'd like both to play though

[Bully]

Milera or Kennedy?

Kennedy for mine.. Who do you have currently?

Kennedy, but I feel Milera will score maybe 5 points less and make the same amount of cash overall. . But the extra 10k can really be useful for a mid rookie.

Milera's job security worries me.. Unless he performs they probably won't pick him, Eddie, Charlie Cameron and Troy Menzel

Worst case scenario is a correction trade to Cocky, hopefully with a bit of change.