Rookie discussions and when to cash

[Bill Manspeaker]

grimley only in my side for the DP

Keep it PG mate

I think the bombers will be copping a bit more than DP this year!

:-X

NOW YOU'RE A MAYUN

[Mat0369]

named in the 3rd NAB game.

he has done well for me in the past.

sub 200k

AARON

He is the other one I have been looking at through the pre-season. He was lining up a lot as a half forward/wing but if he plays he can score. It will basically be between him and Mills at mid 8 or Cannon/Walker and Menadue at M8 (Kerridge DPP option).

[ben_020285]

Ssh - You have to keep some rookies under wraps - Is on my watch list just needing to decide which 4 of Mills, Gresham. Menandue, Dunkley, Matthieson, Clarke,Hibberd, Dunkley to start if all named for rd 1 - Benndey and Kerridge currently in forward line so some decisions come Rd 1 Teams named

This will be easy for you mate. Dunkley and Hibberd haven't been named for NAB3 so very unlikely they will play round 1.

So it's out of Mills, Gresham, Menadue, Mathieson and Clarke. Out of those five, I think Clarke is the least likely to play round 1 and will probably not even play NAB3 once the final 24 have been named.

So Mills, Gresham, Menadue and Mathieson. :)

If only it was this simple - but these are the 4 I have at the moment

It's that simple for the players that Ringo mentioned. There's some others in the mix as well of course.

[_wato]

Going with

Weits, Brown, Hartley, Collins, Adams
Mills, Gresh, Menadue, Matho
King
Ben Ken, Kerridge, Kommer, Grimley

As well as Harwood, Crouch, Libba, Wells etc

Think most of those will play apart from King who is loophole.

[ben_020285]

Going with

Weits, Brown, Hartley, Collins, Adams
Mills, Gresh, Menadue, Matho
King
Ben Ken, Kerridge, Kommer, Grimley

As well as Harwood, Crouch, Libba, Wells etc

Think most of those will play apart from King who is loophole.

No Tippa, mate?

Should play round 1 and uses the footy very well so won't need a whole lot of touches to score ok for a rookie. 102k very appealing too.

[Ringo]

Tippa still needs to be elevated bit if he does is a look - No reason why he should not be though at this stage given the concessions bombers have got.

[RaisyDaisy]

There's an article on herald sun showing all the teams that have spots available

Suns can still get Davis as Ben said. Essendon have 3 spots so surely Tippa gets one

On my phone now, someone link it here if possible

[sammy123]

tippa definately to get promoted

[Gigantor]

You know you are getting desperate when you secretly cheer a significant injury to a starting 22 player because it increases the chances of a rookie lining up round 1.

Sorry Shane Edwards but I really want to lock Menadue in at F6 :)

[Mat0369]

I wouldn't be looking at Broad, he hasn't done anything to really claim a spot in the 22 and there was one really bad bit of play where he stopped and for some reason decided to go short and across the ground to a player that was covered. The ball was intercepted and Port scored a goal. Even in the pre-season it's a bit of video you expect the coach to bring up in the review.

Menadue on the other hand has looked pretty good and played at both ends.

[RaisyDaisy]

Yeah I took out Broad a few weeks ago. Even if he does play his JS would appear to be dicey and he won't score well

Menadue locked

[Keeper27]

Menadue locked

this.

Suns can still get Davis as Ben said. Essendon have 3 spots so surely Tippa gets one

hope so.

Going with

Weits, Brown, Hartley, Collins
Mills, Gresh, Menadue, Matho, Dunkley, Davis
King Cox
Kerridge, Howard, Adams, Tippa

As well as Harwood, Crouch, Libba, Wells etc

Think most of those will play apart from King who is loophole.

similar set up LOL

[AaronKirk]

With the tigers injuries tonight surely Marcon gets promoted from the rookie list and is a good chance to play?

[sammy123]

if broad got a game i would be happy with just 60-70 every week

[Money Shot]

Is Menadue really that much of a lock? Didn't score that well did he?

And I'm not so sure on Howard anymore either.

Chol was always a small chance but didn't do enough last night.

Broad is also a small chance too make my team.