Rookie discussions and when to cash

[nas]

Thoughts on Tom Keough? Got winded bad, but came back on.

Yet another defensive rookie to consider if named Rd 1. Would take 65 SC pts from a rookie every time and 80% TOG. His attack on the ball was great with 9 contested possessions.  Can see playing Rd 1 if Lonergans injury is serious.

Has the DPP M/F also, & has to be promoted off the Rookie list.

[GCSkiwi]

What are Ryan Davis' chances? Swallow gone and JOM no certainty for round 1, will he get a look in? Lots missing from GC last night though...  :-\ Another 102k player and he's done well in 2 NAB outings now. 67 against Brisbane, TOG ??? (says 100% for everyone on here) but then 63 from 46% TOG last night...

[Ricochet]

What are Ryan Davis' chances? Swallow gone and JOM no certainty for round 1, will he get a look in? Lots missing from GC last night though...  :-\ Another 102k player and he's done well in 2 NAB outings now. 67 against Brisbane, TOG ??? (says 100% for everyone on here) but then 63 from 46% TOG last night...

Will get upgraded before McPherson imo. Only issue he has is his tank, so not sure how much that TOG will increase

[GCSkiwi]

What are Ryan Davis' chances? Swallow gone and JOM no certainty for round 1, will he get a look in? Lots missing from GC last night though...  :-\ Another 102k player and he's done well in 2 NAB outings now. 67 against Brisbane, TOG ??? (says 100% for everyone on here) but then 63 from 46% TOG last night...

Will get upgraded before McPherson imo. Only issue he has is his tank, so not sure how much that TOG will increase

I think we'd all be pretty happy with ~60 from a 102k rookie, that'll do me nicely! ;)

[RaisyDaisy]

Rocket was asked about MacPhersons chances of lining up rd1 to which he replied "outside chance for rd1"

[RaisyDaisy]

I've put Dougal Howard on my forward bench too

Scored 80 in his first NAB match and Hamish Hartlett picked him as the player to break out in the Port side this year, so that and his first score is good enough to be a place holder for now

[sammy123]

put a line through pickett after he was cut from gws squad last night

[GM]

I've put Dougal Howard on my forward bench too

Scored 80 in his first NAB match and Hamish Hartlett picked him as the player to break out in the Port side this year, so that and his first score is good enough to be a place holder for now

Correct RD.
Lobbe will definitely need help.

[sammy123]

howard will be in my team pending nab 3 if named

[RaisyDaisy]

Hartley scored 100 last week and is 33 at 1/4 time

Brown and Hartley comfortably starting on field at D5 and 6 for me. Just need two rookies to pop up for bench spots

[Nige]

Watch all those who jumped on the Linc McCarthy bandwagon hop off now.

Still a decent chance to line up Round 1 imo.

[batt]

Watch all those who jumped on the Linc McCarthy bandwagon hop off now.

Still a decent chance to line up Round 1 imo.

He's been out of my team but still in my calculations.  I like the way he plays but he's not a first choice rookie atm.

[RaisyDaisy]

Watch all those who jumped on the Linc McCarthy bandwagon hop off now.

Still a decent chance to line up Round 1 imo.

He's been out of my team but still in my calculations.  I like the way he plays but he's not a first choice rookie atm.

Hasn't been in my side too but I'll keep an eye on him

David King asked Lonergan who he thought could be a surprise Rd 1 inclusion and he said McCarthy

[cortez]

Watch all those who jumped on the Linc McCarthy bandwagon hop off now.

Still a decent chance to line up Round 1 imo.

He's been out of my team but still in my calculations.  I like the way he plays but he's not a first choice rookie atm.

Hasn't been in my side too but I'll keep an eye on him

David King asked Lonergan who he thought could be a surprise Rd 1 inclusion and he said McCarthy

This kid has been in my side from day one and eveyone laughed at me. Kid is a jet, Get on him!

[Ricochet]

Watch all those who jumped on the Linc McCarthy bandwagon hop off now.

Still a decent chance to line up Round 1 imo.

He's been out of my team but still in my calculations.  I like the way he plays but he's not a first choice rookie atm.

Hasn't been in my side too but I'll keep an eye on him

David King asked Lonergan who he thought could be a surprise Rd 1 inclusion and he said McCarthy

This kid has been in my side from day one and eveyone laughed at me. Kid is a jet, Get on him!

Geelong have talked him up for quite a few years too. Has just had a terrible run with injuries