Rookie discussions and when to cash

[batt]

The good news is Hopper was pretty decent sans the score.  Only Ward had more tackles.  57% TOG the worry.

[AaronKirk]

Fortunately only have 2 rookies left on field. Petracca as M8 scored admirably and again cannot put the right one of Dea or Walla on field.

I will look to trade both of Walla and Dea out maybe next week.

[essendon2]

Tippa might be suspended, so if he is that might be a good reason to trade him.
If I downgrade him and upgrade Keays --> Rocky, Collins and Kerridge will be only two non-premiums on my field

[HotTiges]

I still have Tippa, Adams and Kerridge on field..55k in bank so probably can't get a whole lot for Tippa or Adams..

[tommy10]

Tippa might be suspended, so if he is that might be a good reason to trade him.
If I downgrade him and upgrade Keays --> Rocky, Collins and Kerridge will be only two non-premiums on my field

Will prob hold Tippa as he should only get a week. Plus he's scoring more consistent than Dea, so Dea has to go for Bartel. Collins and Tippa on bench.

[RoughRed]

Reckon no trades next week
Rook scores so far will keep them making money - except for Hewlett

[sammy123]

i have 4 rookies left in

dea,DBJ,petracca and smith

[Locinator]

Looks like Smith will be ready to cash this week or next (on his bye).

Going this week to Collins via DPP.

[RaisyDaisy]

So what rookies are actually looking like good downgrade options now?

Trengove and Jansen in the mids for sure

Logan Austin a decent pick down back?

I already have Collins

[Bully]

So what rookies are actually looking like good downgrade options now?

Trengove and Jansen in the mids for sure

Logan Austin a decent pick down back?

I already have Collins

Don't think I'll be looking at any other rookies in defence, will keep a mid spot open for Marcon but that's about it as far as downgrades are concerned. Will use all three trades next week, Trengove for Smith, Jansen for Keays & Menadue to Dahlhaus. That effectively leaves seven trades for 2 upgrades & possibly a guy like Monty as a reserve.

[MontyJnr]

So what rookies are actually looking like good downgrade options now?

Trengove and Jansen in the mids for sure

Logan Austin a decent pick down back?

I already have Collins

Tom Lee probably has a spot now that Goddard & Fisher are both injured.

[timmyparso]

Logan Austin would have very skaky JS
Hombsch will be back very soon

[Raiden]

So what rookies are actually looking like good downgrade options now?

Trengove and Jansen in the mids for sure

Logan Austin a decent pick down back?

I already have Collins

Tom Lee probably has a spot now that Goddard & Fisher are both injured.

I was also thinking Lee might be back soon due to their injuries - Not sold on this Austin guy.

Steward & Jansen both looked good, however not sure on their JS - Steward will probably make room for Hodge

[RaisyDaisy]

Yeah Clarko has shown us rookies don't come in and hold their spot so I'm not considering Stewart

Jansen and Trengove are locks for me, but I'll need one more downgrade option in the next week or two. Not sure who that is though

[desafinado]

I hope Silvagni will come into the Carlton side sometime this year, he has been killing it in the VFL so far.
And i need a FWD rookie downgrade option real bad.