Who replaces Usman Khawaja?

[Nige]

Bancroft didn't really do himself any favours in the Shield game currently going on against the Vics, that said he'll get another innings to have another go.

Maddinson's name was floated, not sure he'll be picked though.

[auscoyote]

Maddinson i didn't think of, don't mind him.

Bancroft did ton up at Adelaide last week though.
Gonna be same ground but different ball.

The more I think about it, the more I believe it has to be one of the WA boys. Bancroft, Klinger, Marsh.

I reckon it depends on the result of this game.

Draw or Lose and go with Klinger or Marsh

Win and go with Bancroft

This

[PowerBug]

The more I think about it, the more I believe it has to be one of the WA boys. Bancroft, Klinger, Marsh.

I reckon it depends on the result of this game.

Draw or Lose and go with Klinger or Marsh

Win and go with Bancroft

Good point.


They said the squad for the 3rd test will be named on Day 5 of this test. Didn't say whether it would be before, during or after the match.

[_wato]

Seeing as Khawaja has proven himself, there is no point playing another young, up and comer when they'll lose their spot to him once he's fit again. Klinger once again top scored today with 70, is in absolute top notch form, played with SA for the majority of his career, and at his age, he will be limited in the tests he plays, so is the perfect replacement for Khawaja while he's on the mend.
Bats at 3, has the experience to compose himself at the highest level, could potentially come into a 1-1 all drawn series and for me is the most likely replacement. Just my opinion though.

[Bill Manspeaker]

Seeing as Khawaja has proven himself, there is no point playing another young, up and comer when they'll lose their spot to him once he's fit again. Klinger once again top scored today with 70, is in absolute top notch form, played with SA for the majority of his career, and at his age, he will be limited in the tests he plays, so is the perfect replacement for Khawaja while he's on the mend.
Bats at 3, has the experience to compose himself at the highest level, could potentially come into a 1-1 all drawn series and for me is the most likely replacement. Just my opinion though.

don't see Voges sticking around for too much longer, 36 now

[Adamant]

Would love to see Maxy Klinger get the nod!

[BratPack]

Way I see it it's like this

Should: Bancroft or Klinger

Will: Marsh

[Nige]

Way I see it it's like this

Should: Bancroft or Klinger

Will: Marsh

Yep, seems the most likely outcome.

[The_Captain]

If shaun marsh gets another go... F|_|K me, hes proven he will never be up to this level.

[elephants]

Two words. Michael Klinger.

[Capper]

I want Klinger to play but it will be Shaun Marsh

[AaronKirk]

On form the selectors have to pick Klinger but i doubt they will.

Maybe if we get the win today they will pick Maxwell. The series will be over and with the Adelaide road pitch they may want to take another bowling option.

However they will likely pick Marsh. I dunno why..... his technique is no good. But we all know that and they still pick him.

[SydneyRox]

Think sentimental fav is Klinger, but I would rather give it to Bancroft and say go out an enjoy it.

[elephants]

Think sentimental fav is Klinger, but I would rather give it to Bancroft and say go out an enjoy it.

This, if we want immediate impact gotta be Klinger. If we want one for the future get Bancroft in there.

It would be a brutal injustice though imo if Klinger never played for Australia and this is really his best opportunity.

[Cookie311993]

I reckon they will think about Maxwell. They will adjust the batting order.
1. Burns
2. Warner
3. Smith
4. Voges
5. Maxwell