Duffield or Hargrave???

[pinochio]

Duffield or Hargrave???

Both had breakout seasons last year.....who will maintain?

Duffield has more upside while hargrave is in a team who should do better???

[Justin Bieber]

it will be a close one for sure. both look in their peaks.

duffield younger and can run off half back and keep racking em up with no tag.
hargrave as you said in a better team but is 29.

not sure on your question but i have hargrave in my team and duffield has been in and out.

[Paddy13]

Go with duffield

[MissPies]

Duffield or Hargrave???

Both had breakout seasons last year.....who will maintain?

Duffield has more upside while hargrave is in a team who should do better???

I would choose Duffield over Hargrave
Why? In 2009 Duffield was selected with more TOG. This boosts a players confidence. Especially since he only had a hand full of games in previous years.
Hargrave who is also a very consistent player, I would be reluctant to choose him due to player/umpire contact. Which makes him a little more risky.

PS. I have Duffield in my DT (this was posted for ..well they know who hahah, I felt like giving just a little)

[Flame]

Duffield..he'll get a lot of work in defence..

[dadsninja]

Duffield or Hargrave???

Both had breakout seasons last year.....who will maintain?

Duffield has more upside while hargrave is in a team who should do better???

Hargrave who is also a very consistent player, I would be reluctant to choose him due to player/umpire contact. Which makes him a little more risky.

Whaaaaaaat? Player/umpire contact? He's been found guilty once and got a fine. And it was a mere brush against him. Its not like he bloody ran through the umpire or anything.

As it turns out, I agree with Duffy over Hargrave, but struth, if that's the rationale then I may rethink my own position!