The Please Don't Recruit Him Thread

[Ringo]

Yep I have legitimate concerns about Aish too. Just looks slow at AFL level and doesn't get anywhere near enough of the pill.

Happy to be proven wrong though, who knows!

Not sure what has gone wrong with Aish this year?  If we did not have so many injuries his form would not of allowed selection in our best 22,

[Toga]

Pendles & Jobe both had questions over their speed as youngsters. But they have one thing that not everyone has and that is class ;) Aish is a classy player (has only shown it in glimpses in the AFL so far) but I wouldn't write him off just yet!

[elephants]

Pendles & Jobe both had questions over their speed as youngsters. But they have one thing that not everyone has and that is class ;) Aish is a classy player (has only shown it in glimpses in the AFL so far) but I wouldn't write him off just yet!

Yeah not writing him off, that would be silly. But early signs aren't great. Like you said though, could definitely be a Watson type one day!

[Toga]

I have faith ;)

[Mat0369]

Outside mids take a bit longer as they build elite tanks. Look at guys like Gaff and Stephen Hill as examples of this. They showed flashes but until they built up their running capacity to the level it is at now they would often be inconsistent regardless of the tag

[Cambo]

Put Aish in a GOOD enviroment and he will develop just nicely.  He has class, there is a lot of upside to him...

[nrich102]

Josh Walker.

[Mat0369]

Josh Walker.

I hope he goes to Brisbane  ;D

[nrich102]

Josh Walker.

I hope he goes to Carlton  :P

[powersuperkents]

Andrew Moore

by that I mean; "I hope he leaves"

Would prefer Butcher to him any day of the week

In regards to who I don't want traded in it's hard, because there are already so many shower players at AFL level to choose from.

I'll probably go with Nick Suban   

[H1bb3i2d]

Rosa.

Do we reeeeeeeally need another 28/29yo recruit? ASADA/WADA bans don't look like a (significant) thing anymore, and that's the only reason for Gwilt/Cooney (which I partially accept, anyway).

[Torpedo10]

Rosa.

Do we reeeeeeeally need another 28/29yo recruit? ASADA/WADA bans don't look like a (significant) thing anymore, and that's the only reason for Gwilt/Cooney (which I partially accept, anyway).

I'd love Colledge though.

[elephants]

Rosa.

Do we reeeeeeeally need another 28/29yo recruit? ASADA/WADA bans don't look like a (significant) thing anymore, and that's the only reason for Gwilt/Cooney (which I partially accept, anyway).

I'd love Colledge though.

I agree, Rosa would have to go to Gold Coast if anywhere but I'm still keen to see if we can convince him to stay.

Otherwise Rosa + next years first rounder for Swallow. Get it done lads

Rosa.

Do we reeeeeeeally need another 28/29yo recruit? ASADA/WADA bans don't look like a (significant) thing anymore, and that's the only reason for Gwilt/Cooney (which I partially accept, anyway).

I'd love Colledge though.

You could be in luck mate, have to see how this Giles thing eventuates

[H1bb3i2d]

Looks like both are staying out. Wouldn't have minded Colledge, but with O'Brien and now possibly Bird, he's not exactly what we need.

[elephants]

Looks like both are staying out. Wouldn't have minded Colledge, but with O'Brien and now possibly Bird, he's not exactly what we need.

Great ;D With Rosa gone we need to keep Colledge!