Rd 17 trades..

Started by Mark, July 19, 2015, 07:25:20 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Mat0369

I had a full team with 3 trades. McGovern is a worry. I only have 3 trades and around 20k so I am screwed

Grazz

Quote from: Mat0369 on July 20, 2015, 12:55:17 AM
I had a full team with 3 trades. McGovern is a worry. I only have 3 trades and around 20k so I am screwed

McGovern out for a month they are saying. :(

Hazza09

8 trades left and need to sort out F6!
McKenzie - Knight and have a option to go Hogan to the following:

Daulhaus
Roughead
Rioli
Goddard
Ziebell
Boomer

Team is sorted! D6 is Oxiey at the moment.

Is Hogan worth trading out?

poolboybob

Quote from: Hazza09 on July 20, 2015, 01:10:26 AM
8 trades left and need to sort out F6!
McKenzie - Knight and have a option to go Hogan to the following:

Daulhaus
Roughead
Rioli
Goddard
Ziebell
Boomer

Team is sorted! D6 is Oxiey at the moment.

Is Hogan worth trading out?

Yeah he is a key forward. Will have too many ordinary scores.

I would go (from that list above) Dahlhaus then Goddard. Also have a look at Bartel if you don't have him already.

Grazz

Agree with Poolboy, there will be games where he scores poorly and a more consistent Prem will alleviate that concern.

no eye deer

Glad I unloaded McGovern last week. My worst trade in of the season (closely followed by Wines). This week Lever out, Mckenzie to backs and in comes Gaz. It will leave me with only Pearce as back cover, but ha gotta do what you gotta do for Gaz.

justaverage

Quote from: no eye deer on July 20, 2015, 08:31:38 AM
Glad I unloaded McGovern last week. My worst trade in of the season (closely followed by Wines). This week Lever out, Mckenzie to backs and in comes Gaz. It will leave me with only Pearce as back cover, but ha gotta do what you gotta do for Gaz.

I have a feeling MJ is just around the corner. Pearce is just holding his shot

no eye deer

Quote from: justaverage on July 20, 2015, 08:41:38 AM
Quote from: no eye deer on July 20, 2015, 08:31:38 AM
Glad I unloaded McGovern last week. My worst trade in of the season (closely followed by Wines). This week Lever out, Mckenzie to backs and in comes Gaz. It will leave me with only Pearce as back cover, but ha gotta do what you gotta do for Gaz.

I have a feeling MJ is just around the corner. Pearce is just holding his shot

Yeah I know, he's only good for 40 odd anyway. Just hoping McKenzie gets a game. I'm leading my cash league with five trades left after this week, so I'll hold tight until the finals.

brodiejay

I've had a terrible year in Supercoach even though I made pretty much every correct starting rookie selection in my original team. My premo selection is what has let me down, so I feel like I kinda need to "swing for the fences".

I'm seriously considering taking a punt on Malceski after two decent scores.

He's stupidly cheap (yes I know it's because he hasn't scored well), but I'm starting to think along the lines that he has runs on the board and might score better now that he has Gaz back.

I'd say it's worthy of mention that Malceski's decent scores coincide with Gazzas return. It just feels like a fairly low risk to trade a Hamling/Lever/Brodie Smith type for Malceski, which could see a potentially high reward based off his scoring history, albeit at a stronger club.

This week I'm considering either:

A) H Bennell and Hamling out for Maynard and Hodge via Burgoyne to mids as D7/M9 cover

Or

B) H Bennell and B Smith out for T Mcdonald and Malceski but losing Burgoyne to mids as solely mids cover.

A) would mean I field Hodge and B Smith with Lever and Maynard as D7/8. Hodge opens D/M link with Burgoyne.

B) would mean I field T Mcdonald and Malceski with Burgoyne as M9 and Lever/Hamling as D7.

For full disclosure, here's my current team before trades:

H Shaw, Houli, Rance, Hibberd, Burgoyne, B Smith  (Lever, Hamling)

Gaz, Fyfe, Rockliff, Pendles, JP Kennedy, Hannebery, Steven, Wines (Steele, N O'brien, Lambert)

Nic Nat, Maric  (T Downie)

R Gray, Deledio, Buddy, Swan, T Mitchell, Bontempelli  (H Bennell, Dale)

Like Natalie Imbruglia... I'm torn.

What should I do?

Mark

PLEASE HELP...

JSelwwod/Lewis to Ablett

Or

McLean (out for 6 weeks) to Goddard and put McKernan on bench as ruck-Forward cover

I think option 2 is better just but really want Ablett but is it worth it

Frozensage

Griffen to Goddard as m9 and d7? Yay?

Thewizz71

Sloane -> GAJ. Leaves me with 4 trades, no cash to cover injuries.

blue


LF

Cripps to Gazza
Krak to Knights
7 Trades left

monga77

My backline needs some attending too,
Shaw, Houli, Birchall, Oxley, Hibberd, Fisher (Andrews, Mckenzie)

Hodge is the logical player I'm missing, currently have $245k in the bank with 8 trades
Just not sure which player to get rid of first??? I'm thinking fisher...

My other trade likely to be a downgrade to generate cash for my F6 upgrade next week