WXV Trade Talk

[GoLions]

Out of curiosity RD/Chumps/others, which 6? I'd take Kelly, and I'd consider Lonergan/Aish/Lmac. Prefer SJ over the rest though.

Joe Daniher surely?

I may be biased but i'd rate him as highly as Jesse Hogan long term.

Menzel in the right environment (now at Adelaide), Aish as an outside mid in a decent Collingwood midfield, Kelly is a gun (just needs more game time)

Boyd with more time long term has more upside than SJ

Marginal with Toumpas at a new club but probably no.

I wouldn't have Lonergan or McDonald over SJ at their current clubs in current roles.

I wouldn't take a key fwd unless they were already basically premos tbh. So that rules out Boyd and Daniher for me. Lonergan only because he should have def status now (otherwise would definitely take SJ over him too), and he showed he could score pretty well at times this year.

[RaisyDaisy]

Exactly what HP said for mine

Daniher will get RUC/FWD DPP. Will be very valuable in a couple of years

Toump and Boyd won't be relevant in SC, but the rest have upside and being so young  have years and years to enter their prime. Way too young to value them correctly, where as we know SJ and Thompson are in the twilight of their careers and will be retired once these kids start entering their prime

[Torpedo10]

We got Daniher pretty cheap.  :P

[Holz]

looking at the top 10 SC scorers is pretty interesting.

Goldy #37
Fyfe #20
Danger #10
Pendles #5
Ablett #40
Hannebary #30
Beams #29
Priddis #R31
Mundy #19
Shaw #48

[meow meow]

looking at the top 10 SC scorers is pretty interesting.

Goldy #37
Fyfe #20
Danger #10
Pendles #5
Ablett #40
Hannebary #30
Beams #29
Priddis #R31
Mundy #19
Shaw #48

Doesn't including a former #1 pick who actually finished in the top 10 suit whatever point you're trying to prove? There's nothing quite like bending the truth blatantly lying to back up your point.

[Toga]

#Truth

[Ringo]

With Stanton signing on for another 12 months offering him up for the best offer. Will suit anyone chasing a premiership next year.  He is super reliable with averaging 90+ each year since 2007 so handy for the right offer. Please PM me with offers.

[Holz]

looking at the top 10 SC scorers is pretty interesting.

Goldy #37
Fyfe #20
Danger #10
Pendles #5
Ablett #40
Hannebary #30
Beams #29
Priddis #R31
Mundy #19
Shaw #48

Doesn't including a former #1 pick who actually finished in the top 10 suit whatever point you're trying to prove? There's nothing quite like bending the truth blatantly lying to back up your point.

Who?

Lids was 11

[Purple 77]

Todd Goldstein   128.81
Nat Fyfe   124.28
Patrick Dangerfield   119.81
Scott Pendlebury   116.23
Gary jnr Ablett   115.50
Dan Hannebery   114.50
David Mundy   113.52
Dayne Beams   113.44
Matt Priddis   113.27
Brett Deledio   112.82

[meow meow]

11 is the new 10

[Holz]

Todd Goldstein   128.81
Nat Fyfe   124.28
Patrick Dangerfield   119.81
Scott Pendlebury   116.23
Gary jnr Ablett   115.50
Dan Hannebery   114.50
David Mundy   113.52
Dayne Beams   113.44
Matt Priddis   113.27
Brett Deledio   112.82

My bad too serious had Shaw at 10.

[Nige]

Did we get the results of the last bunch of trades? Not sure whether I missed the post or the results (or an update) haven't been posted yet.  :)

[Purple 77]

Did we get the results of the last bunch of trades? Not sure whether I missed the post or the results (or an update) haven't been posted yet.  :)

Newp. Still need Buenos Aires, Cape Town, Rio and Tokyo  :)

[Nige]

Did we get the results of the last bunch of trades? Not sure whether I missed the post or the results (or an update) haven't been posted yet.  :)

Newp. Still need Buenos Aires, Cape Town, Rio and Tokyo  :)

Cool, just checking. There's been a fair bit of discussion in this thread since Monday and I thought it might have been lost in all of it.

[RaisyDaisy]

Waiting on the usual suspects :P