WXV Trade Talk

[RaisyDaisy]

It's a new day, surely we can move on and talk about something else?

Our trades get more heat than Dublin!  :-X :'(

I understand that this happens because we do our fair share of trades, and a lot that involve big names but that's just how we roll ;)

Anyway, does anyone have any 70+ depth defenders available? If so, let me know :)

[Nige]

It's a new day, surely we can move on and talk about something else?

Sure can.

Cairo/Nige are definitely the easiest and most reasonable to deal with.

Discuss.   :P

[meow meow]

Why do people continue to trade with Dublin? Holz has shown that he'll slay everyone in the trading department. Turned JOM into Buddy and Libba.

[kilbluff1985]

Why do people continue to trade with Dublin? Holz has shown that he'll slay everyone in the trading department. Turned JOM into Buddy and Libba.

i know a few clubs that don't bother trading with him

[Holz]

Why do people continue to trade with Dublin? Holz has shown that he'll slay everyone in the trading department. Turned JOM into Buddy and Libba.

you leave out important aspects.

I turned JOM into Fyfe (then JOM went down with a long term injury, which you cant predict)

plus I lost Mundy.


most people would say that Mundy + Fyfe for Buddy + Libba is actually a loss.

You can warp stats to show anything you want.

Why would anyone trade with Christchurch.

Brain Lake for Adam Treloar.

You also better be worried if he targets speculative players

Trade 95
Christchurch trade: pick 92
New York trade: Shaun McKernan


Trade with Dublin, look at some of the deals those guys put together..


Dublin Give: David Mundy + Aaron Black + Nat 12 + Nat 75
Dublin Get: Bryce Gibbs

Dublin Give: Pick 12 + Pick 21 + Luke Delaney + Shuan Grigg + Sam Frost + Neville Jetta + George Hewett
Dillos Give: Dane Swan + Paul Chapman

Dublin Trades: Tom Rockliff + Robert Murphy + N57
Dublin Receives: Steele Sidebottom + Shannon Hurn + Daniel Wells + Josh Saunders + N84

All rejected last year for apparently winning by too much. You guys actually saved me from doing all those bad trades.


basically what I would have had with those trades.

Gibbs Swan Zorko Sidebottom Hurn Wells

what I have instead

Sloane Gunston Roughy Mundy Murphy S.Thompson


so thanks everyone.

[Holz]

Why do people continue to trade with Dublin? Holz has shown that he'll slay everyone in the trading department. Turned JOM into Buddy and Libba.

i know a few clubs that don't bother trading with him

I think that's largely because there are a few clubs I dont bother trading with.

[Nige]

Why do people continue to trade with Dublin? Holz has shown that he'll slay everyone in the trading department. Turned JOM into Buddy and Libba.

I ask myself this question every time.

[meow meow]

Haha you got SJ and Grundy for Mundy you silly bugger. Mundy has what, 2 years left? Grundy and SJ have 4 years left.

[RaisyDaisy]

Can't tell if you're serious or just taking the absolute piss. I'd hope it's the latter

[Holz]

just for fun i have loads of trades that turned out poorly

like Barlow for jack Watts
or Lachy Neal for Peanuts.

but instead Ill be nice to Meow and give him what he asked for. My best of the best trades of the last 4 years.

Dublin gives: Picks 1, 56 and 74, Scott D. Thompson and Adam Schneider
Dublin receives: Travis Boak, Brandon Ellis and Alex Rance

Toronto gives: Robbie Gray and Kieran Harper
Dublin gives: Pick 5 and Tommy Walsh

Capetown Gives: Joel Selwood + Lachie Hunter
Dublin Gives: Troy Chaplin + Dale Thomas

Dublin give: Brodie Martin + Matthew Taberner
Pacific give: Matthew Scharenberg.

Christchurch trade: Jarryd Roughead, Rory Sloane, picks 37 and 43
Dublin trade: Dayne Zorko, Travis Boak, picks 12 and 21

Dublin trade: Jaeger O'Meara and Pick 31
Moscow trade: Nat Fyfe

Dublin trade: Aaron Black, Shaun Atley, Pick 10, Pick 49
New York trade: Grant Birchall and Tom Lee

Dublin trade: Zac Clarke, Tom Lee and Pick 67
Moscow trade: Charlie Dixon and Robert Murphy

Dublin trade: Nathan Fyfe, Mitch Clark, Lachie Hunter
Berlin trade: Lance Franklin, Nick Dal Santo, Tom McDonald

[Ricochet]

Capetown Gives: Joel Selwood + Lachie Hunter
Dublin Gives: Troy Chaplin + Joel Selwood

:o #magic

[meow meow]

Best?

Christchurch trade: Jarryd Roughead, Rory Sloane, picks 37 and 43
Dublin trade: Dayne Zorko, Travis Boak, picks 12 and 21

Zorko is younger, more durable and better than Rough, Boak is just as good as Sloane. The age difference between Boak and Sloane isn't that big, and the picks were put to good use. Got Scully with #12 and Kyle Langford with 21. What did you get? Majak Daw.

Hardly call that one a big win.

[meow meow]

Can't tell if you're serious or just taking the absolute piss. I'd hope it's the latter

I didn't mean 4 years each haha. Grundy is signed until the end of 2018, SJ has 2 years left in him. That's 5 ~ 80 seasons from a fwd and defender vs 2 for Mundy at 105 (won't keep it up).

I said Holz gave up JOM > Fyfe > Buddy
                                             > TMac > Libba

and then he said he gave up Mundy too. Pretty sure it was TMac for Libba in your trade so must have been SJ & Grundy for Mundy, which is irrelevant to what I was saying but Holz felt the need to say Mundy + Fyfe for Buddy + Libba, which is actually wrong.

[RaisyDaisy]

Can't tell if you're serious or just taking the absolute piss. I'd hope it's the latter

I didn't mean 4 years each haha. Grundy is signed until the end of 2018, SJ has 2 years left in him. That's 5 ~ 80 seasons from a fwd and defender vs 2 for Mundy at 105 (won't keep it up).

I said Holz gave up JOM > Fyfe > Buddy
                                             > TMac > Libba

and then he said he gave up Mundy too. Pretty sure it was TMac for Libba in your trade so must have been SJ & Grundy for Mundy, which is irrelevant to what I was saying but Holz felt the need to say Mundy + Fyfe for Buddy + Libba, which is actually wrong.

I wasn't actually referring to this (was more so the d!ck waving) but seeing as you're mentioning it you do realize we got Andrew Boston in that deal too right?

[Holz]

Best?

Christchurch trade: Jarryd Roughead, Rory Sloane, picks 37 and 43
Dublin trade: Dayne Zorko, Travis Boak, picks 12 and 21

Zorko is younger, more durable and better than Rough, Boak is just as good as Sloane. The age difference between Boak and Sloane isn't that big, and the picks were put to good use. Got Scully with #12 and Kyle Langford with 21. What did you get? Majak Daw.

Hardly call that one a big win.

Such disrespect to sloane.

He is far far ahead of Boak.

Sloane I rate as my second best scorer behind Goldy.

Danger going slight worry but his last few games and the start of the season showed his worth.

Sloane isnt too far behind rocky and you know I love me some rocky.

Small point Mundy >>> sj Grundy