Selwood..How many weeks ??

[ants]

should get none if buddy got one!

[Swoozie]

I'd be surprised if he was given anything. In real time it wasn't much, lasted less than a second and the player didn't have to come off or anything. The only bad thing was Macmillan pushing Selwood which caused him to push into the shoulder which was the part which most likely hurt him the most. I think he'd be unlucky to be suspended.

This.

Really not as bad as it looks in the still images. It's in no way comparable to the Judd incident like some people are suggesting.

[Belegur]

Should be 0, what the give him could be anything. Keeping anyway, going krak>gaz pushing him as my m9 cover

[RaisyDaisy]

Was all set to get rid of Jelwood this week, but now I have to sweat on Shiels injury. Jelwood might just have to stay

[AaronKirk]

What's GAJ's price going to be?

[honza]

I'd be surprised if he was given anything. In real time it wasn't much, lasted less than a second and the player didn't have to come off or anything. The only bad thing was Macmillan pushing Selwood which caused him to push into the shoulder which was the part which most likely hurt him the most. I think he'd be unlucky to be suspended.

You know why a snap makes a snap sound? Because it's a lot happening in a very short space of time.

Selwood will get at least a week IMO. Very dangerous move.

[AaronKirk]

I'd be surprised if he was given anything. In real time it wasn't much, lasted less than a second and the player didn't have to come off or anything. The only bad thing was Macmillan pushing Selwood which caused him to push into the shoulder which was the part which most likely hurt him the most. I think he'd be unlucky to be suspended.

You know why a snap makes a snap sound? Because it's a lot happening in a very short space of time.

Selwood will get at least a week IMO. Very dangerous move.

Didn't Judd get a few weeks for a similar incident a few years ago?

[honza]

I'd be surprised if he was given anything. In real time it wasn't much, lasted less than a second and the player didn't have to come off or anything. The only bad thing was Macmillan pushing Selwood which caused him to push into the shoulder which was the part which most likely hurt him the most. I think he'd be unlucky to be suspended.

You know why a snap makes a snap sound? Because it's a lot happening in a very short space of time.

Selwood will get at least a week IMO. Very dangerous move.

Didn't Judd get a few weeks for a similar incident a few years ago?

I don't think it will be rated on par with Judd. Judd's just looked like an outright attempt to injure. Selwood was a notch lower on intent and was pushed in the contest as well.

But I think it's safe to say he'll get a week - it's about "the message" (as they'd say in the Wire)

[Big Mac]

I'd be surprised if he was given anything. In real time it wasn't much, lasted less than a second and the player didn't have to come off or anything. The only bad thing was Macmillan pushing Selwood which caused him to push into the shoulder which was the part which most likely hurt him the most. I think he'd be unlucky to be suspended.

You know why a snap makes a snap sound? Because it's a lot happening in a very short space of time.

Selwood will get at least a week IMO. Very dangerous move.

Didn't Judd get a few weeks for a similar incident a few years ago?

Got 4 weeks I think

Not really similar though - Selwood's arms kind of ended up that way during the tackle, Judd actively set out to take the arm and pin it

[LF]

He shouldn't get any weeks,I've seen other players do exactly what Selwood did and got nothing for it.
However the MRP is so ridiculous this year he'll likely get something.

[murrycurry]

I'd be surprised if he was given anything. In real time it wasn't much, lasted less than a second and the player didn't have to come off or anything. The only bad thing was Macmillan pushing Selwood which caused him to push into the shoulder which was the part which most likely hurt him the most. I think he'd be unlucky to be suspended.

You know why a snap makes a snap sound? Because it's a lot happening in a very short space of time.

Selwood will get at least a week IMO. Very dangerous move.

Didn't Judd get a few weeks for a similar incident a few years ago?

I don't think it will be rated on par with Judd. Judd's just looked like an outright attempt to injure. Selwood was a notch lower on intent and was pushed in the contest as well.

But I think it's safe to say he'll get a week - it's about "the message" (as they'd say in the Wire)

If it was about the message, Buddy wouldve been gone for 3 weeks. Buddy didnt cause much of concussion but he sure as hell did it on purpose. The only bad bit of Selwoods tackle was the push from Macmillan. What he did wasn't enough to cause an injury 99% of the time. The other 1% is for those who arent equipped to play footy.

[Cambo]

Doesnt look good but there was no intent to injure.  He was simply holding the arm so the guy could not dispose of the ball...

[Belegur]

Yeah Judds was different, this was a legitimate attempt to tackle imo. Didn't look good though. Who knows what mrp will do, they could come up with litterally any number with their box ticking. If he went to tribunal I'd be pretty confident he could argue it was a tackle, but if mrp give him a week maybe they would cop it

[enzedder]

Would be surprised if he got any weeks. Held his arm in a tackle. No intent to injure. Looked bad because he got rolled over by another player.