mitch clark or sandilands?

Started by Gava, March 21, 2010, 08:19:28 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

mitch clark or sandilands?

mitch clark
6 (30%)
Sandilands
14 (70%)

Total Members Voted: 2

Gava


CFC 1979

if i have to pick clark

he will kick goals this year as well as ruck

Alex7089

I have to go with Sandi.

Looking like he will be the best ruck this year if Cox isn't fit.

elephants


MissPies

Clarke for me
Why? For some reason I think Sandilands looks awkward but that's not really a good reason not to choose him ha.
Clarke for me because he is more of an all rounder. He is so natural.

Prospector_1

Quote from: MissPies on March 21, 2010, 03:03:56 PM
I think Sandilands looks awkward ...

So many that size do. The man's a giant!

nas

Sandi for me. As said a giant & wins pratically every hit out allthough not to his crumbers.

Clark more forward this year with Lue & Charman (baring injuries)

Justin Bieber

Quote from: Prospector_1 on March 21, 2010, 03:27:11 PM
Quote from: MissPies on March 21, 2010, 03:03:56 PM
I think Sandilands looks awkward ...

So many that size do. The man's a giant!

If he looks awkward, have you seen yao ming. he's 15cm taller than big sandi.

Alex7089

Yao Ming made Lebron James look like a midget when he stood next to him.

Justin Bieber

hey if i stand next to them, i'll probably be up to their waist.

Alex7089

I'd be up to his pecks...

If I stood on some stilts.

jr0ck88

I severly doubt Clark will score as good as last year - he wont actually be playing ruck (Charman and Leunberger have that locked in), and he apparently isn't even a third tall forward option (Staker has been flagged for that). Where does this leave him? I guess he'll meander across half back or half forward, or at the most play as a tall wingman like Jared Brennan.  Bottom line is, he wont get 20+ possesions, 5 tackles and 15 hit outs a match this year.

Sandliands probably will dominate this year, coming off his best year and having a better understanding of what to do when he isnt rucking. Will have an impact down forward, and always is good for 30 hit outs.

Justin Bieber

Quote from: jr0ck88 on March 22, 2010, 06:09:53 AM
I severly doubt Clark will score as good as last year - he wont actually be playing ruck (Charman and Leunberger have that locked in), and he apparently isn't even a third tall forward option (Staker has been flagged for that). Where does this leave him? I guess he'll meander across half back or half forward, or at the most play as a tall wingman like Jared Brennan.  Bottom line is, he wont get 20+ possesions, 5 tackles and 15 hit outs a match this year.

If he isn't in the ruck likely going to play CHB or CHF. will run off half back/forward if named there. but since charman is injured, might be needed to ruck early on.

Flame

Sandi will dominate undersized ruckman..but clark will still be a good pick up

Sandi be a peck for me..