Wines vs Ward vs Ebert

[colmullet]

Have this decision to make to, at this stage going with Ward, Ebert can really fluctuate alot and Wines is still young and had an injury or two so unsure whether he can run out the season to a high output.

[jfitty]

Ebert's year last year is definitely a turn off, but he's only just turned 25 (I thought he was much older) so perhaps natural progression and another year in the midfield means he could keep his scoring up?

[H1bb3i2d]

So I'm trading out Rocky as I don't think he'll be back next week. I like Wines from this poll, already have Ward. What are people's thoughts on Treloar (or even Shiel) over Wines though?

[H1bb3i2d]

Treloar faces: Pies, North, Tigers, Saints, Suns, Cats, Freo, Bombers, Port, Swans, Carlton, Dees.

There are a lot of sides I can see him dominating there! (His biggest games so far have been against the Blues, Lions, Saints, Suns and Dees.)

[DoctorRush]

So I'm trading out Rocky as I don't think he'll be back next week. I like Wines from this poll, already have Ward. What are people's thoughts on Treloar (or even Shiel) over Wines though?

I have both Shiel & Treloar and love the two of them playing kick to kick on the weekends.
Both good kids who are exciting to watch which makes supercoach more enjoyable.
Unlike Bellchambers... I'm a Bombers fan so I'm forced to watch how bad he is. I'm so annoyed the ruck loophole was never tested. You can guarantee it will be now that I've dumped him.

[Jay]

Treloar faces: Pies, North, Tigers, Saints, Suns, Cats, Freo, Bombers, Port, Swans, Carlton, Dees.

There are a lot of sides I can see him dominating there! (His biggest games so far have been against the Blues, Lions, Saints, Suns and Dees.)

Only just realised that Treloar is as cheap as he is... Something to consider  :-X

[H1bb3i2d]

Treloar faces: Pies, North, Tigers, Saints, Suns, Cats, Freo, Bombers, Port, Swans, Carlton, Dees.

There are a lot of sides I can see him dominating there! (His biggest games so far have been against the Blues, Lions, Saints, Suns and Dees.)

Only just realised that Treloar is as cheap as he is... Something to consider  :-X

Yep, he's put in a couple of really low scores, but who hasn't this year.

[Jay]

Treloar faces: Pies, North, Tigers, Saints, Suns, Cats, Freo, Bombers, Port, Swans, Carlton, Dees.

There are a lot of sides I can see him dominating there! (His biggest games so far have been against the Blues, Lions, Saints, Suns and Dees.)

Only just realised that Treloar is as cheap as he is... Something to consider  :-X

Yep, he's put in a couple of really low scores, but who hasn't this year.

Wines ;)

[HotTiges]

Hmm ward vs treloar vs shiel...

[Blues Blues Blues]

Hmm ward vs treloar vs shiel...

I'm now looking at Treloar! BE of 92 so he can wait a week and shouldn't jump too much

[jfitty]

Callan Ward is only in 2.8% of teams! I find that a bit bizarre. It seems like the only people who own him are on FanFooty haha.

For comparison, Treloar is in 5.6%, and Shiel 12.9%.

[Samsturmfels]

Wines, just love watching him.
I'm also turned off from Picking Gws mids, because I still have griffen

[Diesels Pups]

I'm one of those with Ward and I went Ebert over Wines today which is a risk but turned out alright tonight. Trying to be a little different without being stupid.

[H1bb3i2d]

I'm one of those with Ward and I went Ebert over Wines today which is a risk but turned out alright tonight. Trying to be a little different without being stupid.

Very nice.

[Keith Urban]

I'm one of those with Ward and I went Ebert over Wines today which is a risk but turned out alright tonight. Trying to be a little different without being stupid.

Great pick :) was in a similar position and went with Wines, he was lacking in efficiency tonight and still managed an 88 so should bounce back, Ebert looked very solid though.