hodge Simpson or yeo?

[mark44]

Trading rocky out to a premium defender via goodes
Already have Shaw Murphy newnes

Can afford hodge but is it worth just grabbing yeo or Simpson?

[dicko_]

I like Simpson, and he will probably produce roughly what he was for his entire career, being an average between 90-95. Pretty solid value there in my opinion.

However Hodge is arguably the best defender this year. Seems to be getting a decent amount of mid time, and will deliver big scores.
Never keen on bolters, so that is as much thought as I'd give Yeo.

The difference between Hodge and Simpson is only $60k, so it depends if you could use that cash elsewhere in the short term, but Hodge seems like a very good scorer, and plays in a team that is more likely to be on top than Simpson.

[steven3]

Hodge > Simpson > Yeo for me
However Hodge may get rested near the end of the season in finals and he is 60k more than Simpson
I would take Simpson if you could use the 60k well otherwise Hodge

[eaglesman]

I reckon Yeo yeo

[Big Mac]

Simmo

Add a poll

[mark44]

Don't know how lol, hodge has had big games but only two tons

[Big Mac]

Don't know how lol, hodge has had big games but only two tons

There should be 5 buttons down the bottom of the page

The middle one should be "add poll"

[mark44]

Thanks poll added,

I've gone hodge, just not sure on him being rested, so tempted to go yeo lol, he will play unless hurt

[Holden the ball]

i need a player with the round 13 bye defender thoughts on getting yeo in i have 516k

[RaisyDaisy]

Gotta have at least one of Simmo or Hodge in your team I think

I started with Simmo, and plan on getting Hodge soon

[mark44]

I  went with yeo just over Simpson

I didn't go hodge as he could get rested later

I watched yeo on the weekend and he looks great, he's an awesome mark, it was shocking conditions in that game with the wind but he still managed 80odd, I think he's a good pickup, looks like he's one of the leaders out there on the field

Simpson is still a lock though

[justaverage]

Simpson and/or Smith in next week for me

[tor01doc]

27 6 4!

Hodge it is then. Just not this week.

[plumdog millionaire]

Simpson, will play more midfield and attend more centre bounces as he has now

[Grufflez]

Hodge>Simpson just.