Which POD Rnd 11 defender?

[Hoggyz_a_legend]

I have $500k to spend on a defender. Currently my defence is Shaw, Gibson, Newnes, Pittard, Oxley, Saad. Trading Rocky to a defender via McKenzie.

Houli has a bit of cash to lose plus is playing Freo so I'm not keen on him yet, and Simpson is too prone to a late out and a tag imo.

It's pretty much a flip of a five-sided coin atm...

[jfitty]

I'd still go Simpson out of that lot.

Simpson is too prone to a late out and a tag imo.

The odd tag perhaps, but late out? He was withdrawn from the squad the day before in round 6 this year which at least wasn't a traditional late out.

Other than that he missed 2 games in 2012 when Sharrod Wellingham broke his jaw, otherwise the last possible time he was a (game day) late out would be in 2005  :P

[Asparagus]

I am in the same boat and have shaw, newnes, ibbo,saad, ox, KMac (goods, mckenzie)

Pretty sure I am going Bob Murphy over simmo as the dogs have a good run coming up and the blues are terrible.

[RaisyDaisy]

Same position for me, and I'm grabbing Bob I think

Already have TMac, Shaw, Simpson and LOLmumba and cant afford Hodge