plz rate updated version :)

[grass73]

back-goddard,enright,hodge,waite,hunt,ladson,mguire-waters,silvagni
mid-gaz,swan,gibbs,mart,barlow-shuey,bastinac
ruck-tippett,nic nat-warnock,grimley
forward-goodes,riewoldt,gia,gray,hall,zeiball,gumby-rockliff,hitchcock

[Torress]

for starters it appears that u are missing one midfielder..
cool count atleast 13 keepers there i'd say, thats cool..
i'm guessing u are looking to upgrade nicnat for a good prem ruck then tippet being no.2 in the end. nicnat will not be a top5 ruckmen come season end as he is not a no.1 ruckmen.
i think u have a good foundation - perhaps now tinker with a few to get overall consistency around the ground.. ask yourself if (besides absolute keepers) does each player have upside?? u haven't mucked around with the top shelf products. gaz, swan, GODdard, goodes, roo. i think its cool to have one ultimate lock in each position if thats how u want to roll regardless of price. IMO u can save a significant amount of money if u downgrade the overpriced pair of swan and goodes. if u have gaz u don't need to start swanny - u have goddard there for backup captain and even hodge. u can save yourdelf atleast 50k or so even if u drop to NDS - he is totally worth it for SC. or even go selwood, bartel, pendles - all will score well. and goodes - its difficult to talk this guy down and i rate him highly - he is an absolute sensation of a footballer!!! but it is well publicised he is going perm. CHF - goodes has historically accumulated big scores as he is a roving big man almost having a free reign to do as he pleases. loss of cattle means he HAS to be a target for the swannies from now on and rely upon younger guys to win it from contests now. pick goodes up l8er down the track at a much juicer price - u can't say that @ 600k he has upside - Pav for instance has obvious upside at 523k - the bloke kicks 70 goals every year. with almost 200k pocketed here u can upgrade somewhere else - ie maybe upgrade waite for harbrow, or someone as waite is not a good bloke to start with as he is underdone, or make ur two starting rookies in ur back/forward lines a midpricer... anyway i've really made a long post here - hope this helps

[grass73]

i forgot selwood but thanx youve left a few descions for me to ponder :) again thnx 4 the post:)

[The R Soul]

torress has some good points there shaw to pendals sounds better  ::)

[The R Soul]

swan i ment