Bob Murphy or Kade Simpson

[YoungGun]

getting one of these boys in this week, similar price. likely the idea of Bob as a POD and being in a good doggies side. not sure I want Simpson if carlton are losing every week by 10 goals even though I know that doesn't mean he cant score well

[Big Mac]

Simmo

Has gone 90+ half a dozen times and will do it again

[HotTiges]

Either one of these old campaigners should do the job.. both reliable enough

[AaronKirk]

On prior 90+ seasons you would go Simpson but as you say Carlton are a very shower team at the moment so you have to look basically at what we have seen this season.

Simmo has only gone above 90 on 3 occasions and only once from Round 3 onward. Only 2 tons. However has not gone below 70

Murph has got 5 tons and 2 80's in 9 games, he can throw the odd shocker in with a score in the 50's and 60's

Simmo 477k and in 9.1% of teams v Murphy 471k in 4.1% of teams

The bulldogs have a good draw after the byes whilst Carlton couldn't beat a blind man with no arms.

I asked myself the same question 2 weeks ago and went with Bob and he has scored 81 and 102.

I know Simpson went big 2 weeks ago but I just have an uneasy feeling about Carlton players who are not young.

[YoungGun]

On prior 90+ seasons you would go Simpson but as you say Carlton are a very shower team at the moment so you have to look basically at what we have seen this season.

Simmo has only gone above 90 on 3 occasions and only once from Round 3 onward. Only 2 tons. However has not gone below 70

Murph has got 5 tons and 2 80's in 9 games, he can throw the odd shocker in with a score in the 50's and 60's

Simmo 477k and in 9.1% of teams v Murphy 471k in 4.1% of teams

The bulldogs have a good draw after the byes whilst Carlton couldn't beat a blind man with no arms.

I asked myself the same question 2 weeks ago and went with Bob and he has scored 81 and 102.

I know Simpson went big 2 weeks ago but I just have an uneasy feeling about Carlton players who are not young.

I'm feeling the same way. really like murphy

[barlowlove]

How would you guys compare these two with Gibbo? Going to bring in one of the three

[YoungGun]

How would you guys compare these two with Gibbo? Going to bring in one of the three

I would have Gibbo 3rd of the 3 just because he is more key position. but I don't have any proper facts to back me up really. I'm liking murphy because the dogs love it in his hands and they are good enough to get it to him each week now

[AaronKirk]

How would you guys compare these two with Gibbo? Going to bring in one of the three

Gibbo has the chance at times to go back to playing KPP instead of on the 3rd tall so that would be a concern but not enough for me not to have him. I started the year with Gibbo and he has been very good.

4 tons with 2 70's and 2 80's from Gibson.

The tons being against Geelong, Port Adelaide, Sydney and Gold Coast so 3 against likely top 8 opposition.

He is a solid option

[Raiden]

Bob, dogs have a great run also.

[RaisyDaisy]

Already have Simmo, so might grab Bob and have both :)

[Capper]

Simmo my pick as he will see more of the ball in the backline, hopefully its not flying over his head everytime

[plumdog millionaire]

Have both, fun times all round

[Gigantor]

Have both, fun times all round

[Ricochet]

Simmo for me but Dogs have a lovely draw coming up

[Asparagus]

It's a toss up and I guess if you are into PODs then Bobs your man.
As long as Barker doesn't get "creative" then Simmo just over Bob I reckon.