The Elephant In The Room

Started by RaisyDaisy, May 23, 2015, 08:52:50 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

batt

I'll be bringing him in next week almost certainly.

He's Joel Selwood.  He can't stay like this forever.

Hazza09

Quote from: batt on June 01, 2015, 02:35:00 PM
I'll be bringing him in next week almost certainly.

He's Joel Selwood.  He can't stay like this forever.

I would avoid him....he hasnt been himself this season. Hasnt had much influence in games recently

honza

Guys relax

Selwood Season starts soon.

Big Mac

Quote from: honza on June 01, 2015, 06:10:59 PM
Guys relax

Selwood Season starts soon.

He's done it once before

Hardly 'Selwood Season''

PICCOLLO

Quote from: ronl on June 01, 2015, 09:30:28 AM
As well as Selwood, I've got his buddy Jobe taking up space.  After watching yesterday's game closely I'm convinced that Watson is carrying injuries, physical and mental. Selly will probably come good but I don't think Watson will, not for awhile at least  Want to get rid of him now that he has become such a liability, but sensibly will probably hold until the byes and pray for a miracle.

Watson is injured and I don't think he's playing this week.  I'd trade him.

Re: Selwood.  I don't think there's an upside to trading him if you have him as he's leaked most of his cash and I'm sure you guys have other positions to upgrade.  At worst he becomes you're M9 in a few weeks.  A big score isn't far off.

sidvicious

Jelwood at 480 after next week 4 bye cover mmm

honza


jfitty

Quote from: batt on June 01, 2015, 02:35:00 PM
I'll be bringing him in next week almost certainly.

He's Joel Selwood.  He can't stay like this forever.

Yep, agree!

Looking for a round 13 bye mid to bring in next week, and Rich > Selwood for about 50k is looking really appealing

Money Shot

I hope he comes good because I'm sick of those below 100 scores :-\

eaglesman

Definitely would not be selling selwood of I had him ... But I do not expect him to return to the form you will be expecting

From memory, when he went nuts last year he was scoring 2, 3 or 4 goals a game ... I don't see selwood repeating that because I don't see the cats having their way with sides like they have in times gone by

Just my opinion

Capper

I have had Jelwood from the start and wont be trading him sideways ever.

Changes are if he gets injured he might miss one and play on a broken leg

no eye deer

Keep him if you've got him.Trades are scarce this year. I wouldn't be trading him in though.

batt

Soo, Selwood Season is right around the corner!  Right guys?! Riiight?

Grufflez

Quote from: batt on June 08, 2015, 08:11:06 PM
Soo, Selwood Season is right around the corner!  Right guys?! Riiight?

I'll def consider him if he backs it up this week with a 110+ , still concerned about the Cats sliding and SJ dropping off means he doesnt take attention off of Jelwood half of the time.....Knew Selwood would come good at some stage but that may only be 110 this year or w/e, watching closely next week.

jfitty

Quote from: Grufflez on June 08, 2015, 09:36:34 PM
Quote from: batt on June 08, 2015, 08:11:06 PM
Soo, Selwood Season is right around the corner!  Right guys?! Riiight?

I'll def consider him if he backs it up this week with a 110+ , still concerned about the Cats sliding and SJ dropping off means he doesnt take attention off of Jelwood half of the time.....Knew Selwood would come good at some stage but that may only be 110 this year or w/e, watching closely next week.

I'm not too sure what to think of Selwood myself, mainly for the reasons you listed.

Need to bring in at least one round 13 bye player this week. Selwood is so tempting, but guys like Wines, Ward and Ebert are really attracting me. Not having Selwood would be a great POD too if he doesn't average more than 105 for the season..