DT Who to Field

Started by Ricochet, May 22, 2015, 05:50:06 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

whorya

was thinking the same:

yeh my issue is


MIDS

2 from
CEY vs Cripps vs Rich vs VDB

Rich and VDB?

BACKS

1 from
Lever vs Mckenzie vs McK

Lever just?

Rusty00

With all the outs this week I have to field either N Brown or Amon.

Obviously N Brown is a last resort however if I pick Amon to start it means I will have no emergency in the mids which seems risky especially as I have Lewis.

So choice is
Amon on the field, N Brown as defensive emergency or
N Brown on the field. Amon as mid emergency
?

Ringo

Brown may repeat his efforts in round 5 & 6 and score well for you. So worth the risk with Amon on bench

My 2 decisions

Iin mids Cripps or CEY

and this is how desperate I am in forwards Dale or Webb with my forward outs.

Ricochet

Quote from: Rusty00 on June 04, 2015, 09:54:04 PM
With all the outs this week I have to field either N Brown or Amon.

Obviously N Brown is a last resort however if I pick Amon to start it means I will have no emergency in the mids which seems risky especially as I have Lewis.

So choice is
Amon on the field, N Brown as defensive emergency or
N Brown on the field. Amon as mid emergency
?
There's not much between the two anyway mate, you might lose 20-30points in a worst case scenario

Chelskiman

Tarrant or Bellchambers?

The_Captain

Amon over n brown.

Tarrant of Bellend... i mean bellchambers.

whorya

am i made in keeping oxley - till rd12 byes

and instead going rich to shaw via dpp?

and also keeping rocky as i dont want to burn the trade and long term could be a good unique

Rusty00

Oxley will lose a bit of cash before his bye, which could turn into a lot of cash if he throws in another poor score or 2.

It's not the worst move keeping Rocky, however it could make it difficult to field enough players during the byes, particularly Round 12. If you can cover for that it may turn out to be a smart move saving the trade, especially if he comes back sooner than expected.

henry

Quote from: Rusty00 on June 05, 2015, 04:24:14 PM
Oxley will lose a bit of cash before his bye, which could turn into a lot of cash if he throws in another poor score or 2.

It's not the worst move keeping Rocky, however it could make it difficult to field enough players during the byes, particularly Round 12. If you can cover for that it may turn out to be a smart move saving the trade, especially if he comes back sooner than expected.

Thats my logic, have other concerns Im using my trades on this week, have a feeling he will come back closer to 2-3 weeks rather than 4-6, he's a very tough bloke. Also probably saving the trade is my bigger concern at this stage.

Vindicate

Quote from: whorya on June 05, 2015, 04:05:42 PM
am i made in keeping oxley - till rd12 byes

and instead going rich to shaw via dpp?

and also keeping rocky as i dont want to burn the trade and long term could be a good unique

My concern with Oxley is whether or not he will actually play. He is named on the extended bench which will not be shortened until Saturday. He struggled a fair bit last week as well so I would say there might be quite a high risk there. With popular bench options in McKenzie and Lever out I am just moving him on this week