Touk Miller

[Holz]

your making me cry.

Ablett to Sloane and Miller to NVB killed my season.

my alternative Ablett to Fyfe would have me about 40,000 ranks higher.

sorry just had to vent.

on topic i would keep the guy in form.

[Samsturmfels]

your making me cry.

Ablett to Sloane and Miller to NVB killed my season.

my alternative Ablett to Fyfe would have me about 40,000 ranks higher.

sorry just had to vent.

on topic i would keep the guy in form.

+1
miller to NVB has really hurt

[Ricochet]

Appreciate people saying how good he has been  - I agree!

BUT

After Collingwood it's Hawthorn, Sydney, Freo, BYE

Surely he wont do as well vs the 3 best teams in the comp back to back to back?

The talk of keeping him for byes I see as irrelevant, as JPK shares the same by so it's apples for apples

Wouldn't worry too much about Pies and Hawks, they're not too defensive in the middle
Pies 100+ scores against them in last 3 weeks... 8, 7, 0 (against Carlton lol)
Hawks 100+ scores against them in last 3 weeks... 4, 8, 5

[AlexIsOnFire]

Have to back him in at Metricon against the pies.

Will move him next week

[GCSkiwi]

I'll be holding Cripps, CEY and Miller for as long as I can, but I also already have JPK.

For you RD I think Miller to JPK is probably a good move either this week or next. JPK goes up 14k if he gets his projected 117, bit of a gamble as I think he'll either excel (125+) or throw out a high 90-low 100 odd against the Hawks.
Miller projected to go up 24k if he gets 91... which is doable for him but pies have sidey back which could be a bad thing.

In short I think you could make a small financial gain (~10-20k at most) if you hold Miller this week, but will more than likely make a score gain if you trade this week, depends what's most important. If Miller has a good game and JPK has a bad one then I think they'll probably score similarly, otherwise JPK will easily outscore Miller. To lose points on that JPK would have to have a shocker and Miller have a blinder...

[RaisyDaisy]

Cheers Kiwi

I'm starting to lean towards keeping him for at least another week, because I might have come up with some other trade ideas for my team

I am super keen to get JPK in my side, and have been for weeks now but I might just have to be patient and wait another week or so

[tor01doc]

Cheers Kiwi

I'm starting to lean towards keeping him for at least another week, because I might have come up with some other trade ideas for my team

I am super keen to get JPK in my side, and have been for weeks now but I might just have to be patient and wait another week or so

RD,

Maybe OUT Vanders and swing McKenzie to M10 and get Lever.

Next week grab BOTH Rocky and JPK as 2 of Clark, Miller, Saad and Cripps will be ripe.

[RaisyDaisy]

Already have McKenzie in the mids so cant really do that, and don't want to swing another defender into the mids to get Lever for Vanders

I've come up with a plan to turn Ox into JPK via McKenzie which I think I'll be going with now, so Miller stays for a bit longer :)

[tor01doc]

Already have McKenzie in the mids so cant really do that, and don't want to swing another defender into the mids to get Lever for Vanders

I've come up with a plan to turn Ox into JPK via McKenzie which I think I'll be going with now, so Miller stays for a bit longer :)

Saad swings with McKenzie?

[dmac07]

Thinking I might hold and do Miller to Rockliff next week, both likely to raise about 20k this week, and gives me another week to look at Rocky. Also, it'll be the difference between me having Rance and Tarrant on field this week, instead of Rocky and McIntosh/Lever. More points this week, same price for the trade next week. Win win, I hope.

[devize]

Yep, I brought Treloar in this week as he's going to go up a fair bit and I'll do the Miller > Rockliff trade next week if Rocky goes okay. I have too many Rd 12 players so Miller has to make way for my bye structure.

[Nige]

I grabbed Gray this week and don't have the funds to bring Rocky in as well, but I'm thinking Touk -> Rocky next week is almost certainly the plan for me. Plus, it means I don't use two trades this week which I guess is a good thing considering I only have 19 left (after using one this week).

[PICCOLLO]

upgrade or hold. Been solid.

[H1bb3i2d]

Just can't imagine not having a better option to trade out this week instead. And if you don't, I envy you!

[PICCOLLO]

Yep, I brought Treloar in this week as he's going to go up a fair bit and I'll do the Miller > Rockliff trade next week if Rocky goes okay. I have too many Rd 12 players so Miller has to make way for my bye structure.

+1