Parker V Treloar V Buddy?

[Carn]

I wanted to do one up one down but don't like the down. So though i might do another up: CEY>...

Current mids:
Fyfe pendles JPK Selwood
Danger Rocky Cripps Miller
(Heeney CEY Krak)

Fwd:
Gray Swan Martin
Bonts Tmitch Tarrant
(Lonie Clark)

[Ricochet]

In the mids you'd probably want to go SJ for bye structure. He's great value for money atm but obvioulsy a bit risky

If not him then grab Buddy, a big score has to be just around the corner

[RaisyDaisy]

Geez both of those lines are strong

I'd take a guess that your defence and or rucks are weak - maybe upgrade there instead because these current lines are good enough for now

[Carn]

Geez both of those lines are strong

I'd take a guess that your defence and or rucks are weak - maybe upgrade there instead because these current lines are good enough for now

Ruck:
Goldy NicNat

Def :
Shaw Newnes Higgins
Saad Oxe McIntosh
(Brown McKenzie)

Def is weakest but still getting ok scores. Any suggstions?

[PICCOLLO]

Treloar is your man.

Good for your byes and he's set to go up from 490

My rationale is looking at the gain ull get from  replacing a mid rookie vs a fwd rookie

Tarrant(80) buddy (100) 20 points

Miller(80) treloar (105+) 25 points

And ull be offloading a r12er for a r13er.
Not to mention tarrant has more money to make.
I think touk has 2 more rises, probably not that large and signed a new contract, which for some means you take the foot off.  Not sure I agree but its still the best option.

[Jimmykidd]

Treloar is very Tempting. Thinking about getting him too. I would like to see a bit more consistency from him first. Although I could say that about half the mids this year. Wouldn't be the worst m8 ever

[PICCOLLO]

Treloar is very Tempting. Thinking about getting him too. I would like to see a bit more consistency from him first. Although I could say that about half the mids this year. Wouldn't be the worst m8 ever

Averaging more than selwood.
Had a bad one when they got pumped against wce.
Griffen out might help him?

Im strongly considering him but these 60s are concerning.

[Ricochet]

Treloar is very Tempting. Thinking about getting him too. I would like to see a bit more consistency from him first. Although I could say that about half the mids this year. Wouldn't be the worst m8 ever

Averaging more than selwood.
Had a bad one when they got pumped against wce.
Griffen out might help him?

Im strongly considering him but these 60s are concerning.

Griffen is fine this week mate, he'll play apparently

[RaisyDaisy]

Geez both of those lines are strong

I'd take a guess that your defence and or rucks are weak - maybe upgrade there instead because these current lines are good enough for now

Ruck:
Goldy NicNat

Def :
Shaw Newnes Higgins
Saad Oxe McIntosh
(Brown McKenzie)

Def is weakest but still getting ok scores. Any suggstions?

With your current mid setup I'd be upgrading your defence to at least get Tosh off the field

[Jimmykidd]

Selwood vs treloar?

At the moment you'd say treloar but selwood there's only upside

[Carn]

So much love in the poll for Parker. Can JPK, Hanners, Mitchell, Buddy & Parker all score well?

[Jimmykidd]

Absolutely they can. Showed they could last week. More so than the gws mids

[RaisyDaisy]

So much love in the poll for Parker. Can JPK, Hanners, Mitchell, Buddy & Parker all score well?

They've done so in previous years, with McVeigh and Jack too even without Mitchell

[Huttabito]

So much love in the poll for Parker. Can JPK, Hanners, Mitchell, Buddy & Parker all score well?

Parker (148), Mitchell (128), JPK (112), Buddy (119) and Hanners (111) last week.
Another 3 Swans scored over 100 aswell, so to answer the question, yes!

[ants]

So much love in the poll for Parker. Can JPK, Hanners, Mitchell, Buddy & Parker all score well?

Parker (148), Mitchell (128), JPK (112), Buddy (119) and Hanners (111) last week.
Another 3 Swans scored over 100 aswell, so to answer the question, yes!

there not going to do that every week let alone every 2 weeks