Which ruck for the rest of the season?

Started by murrycurry, May 18, 2015, 12:38:29 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

murrycurry

Leaning towards Mumford at this stage but I'm open for suggestions, cheers!

The_Captain

Jacobs for durability i reckon. Mummy seems injury prone.

jfitty

Go Mummy. Coming into some form and is definitely a POD.

ronl

Maric was playing at his best on the weekend, especially around the ground, and when he's off the leash like that he's as good as anyone.  Maybe he's broken the shackles, and he is more suited to a wide-open run for your life game style which Richmond employed against the Pies. But will it continue?

Raiden

Sauce, i don't think Mumford has every played a full season without breaking down @ some point and missing a few games.

Blues Blues Blues

Sauce. Not As exciting as Mummy but he's reliable and consistent

blue


PICCOLLO

Got Sauce last week. No regrets.  Paddy Ryder will be cheap soon though if you're happy to wait a few..

murrycurry

Hadn't given Sauce too much consideration, hes had three shockers in between big scores. Seems to have a big variation in scores this year

Desired7

I brought in Nic Nat for Jesse Hogan Last week hoping he would lift on his recent performances, but im still backing him to lft in a couple of week. i dont think his too far away from scoring some good scores soon so hopefully he comes good. was tossing up between him and mummy and saunce, but went the risky option and hoping it repays me throughout the rest of the season

Capper

Mummy but he might miss a game or two

Grufflez

#11
Quote from: Desired7 on May 19, 2015, 02:50:51 PM
I brought in Nic Nat for Jesse Hogan Last week hoping he would lift on his recent performances, but im still backing him to lft in a couple of week. i dont think his too far away from scoring some good scores soon so hopefully he comes good. was tossing up between him and mummy and saunce, but went the risky option and hoping it repays me throughout the rest of the season

Big mistake mate, most of us with him wish we could offload him, new ruck scoring system in SC is more reflecting on what he actually contributes now...

I have Maric and would take Blitz at 490k, becoming an important player to us at Geelong....until teams work out how to deal with him/ Sauce is a safe bet as well.

Locinator

Goldstein and Martin are my top 2 rucks. Get the one you don't have

Holz

Jacobs Martin Mummy Maric they should all average similar.

Mummy and Maric more of an injury concern
Martin has Burger (who could be a factor at some stage)
Jacobs basically alone and missed one game in 3 years.

I went Jacobs this week.

Jimmykidd

Any of goldy, Jacobs, mummy, Martin and maric. Throw blitz in there as a wild card. Rest are irrelevant. I've got godly and nicnat And if I didn't have so many other problems nicnat would be goneeee.