Which ruck for the rest of the season?

Started by murrycurry, May 18, 2015, 12:38:29 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Blues Blues Blues

Quote from: Jimmykidd on May 19, 2015, 04:42:46 PM
Any of goldy, Jacobs, mummy, Martin and maric. Throw blitz in there as a wild card. Rest are irrelevant. I've got godly and nicnat And if I didn't have so many other problems nicnat would be goneeee.

Yep, he's surviving by the skin of his teeth at moment and lucky I have more pressing issues

AaronKirk

Jacobs will become my R1 in a few weeks. He has the best durability out of himself and Mumford. Not that interested on Martin or Maric.

RaisyDaisy

Jacobs for mine

Has a good bye, and is durable

Frozensage

Mum looks good. But sucks me in every year. Then gets injured for2 month.

RaisyDaisy

Quote from: RaisyDaisy on May 19, 2015, 06:40:29 PM
Jacobs for mine

Has a good bye, and is durable

Actually, Mumford would be my pick, but Sauce for his bye

barlowlove

Looking to trade a fwd rookie to a premo ruck via Belly this week. No other upgrades are urgent and Belly at R2 is killing me.

I can afford anyone except Stef Martin, so I'm looking at Mumford, Maric, Jacobs and Blicavs.

-Can Blicavs keep it up? Doesn't have the ceiling of the others
-Jacobs has a tough draw coming up and through the byes
-Are Mummy or Maric durable enough?

Probably leaning towards Mumford, interested to see what others are doing

RaisyDaisy

Check out this thread for some opinions and advice mate :)

http://forum.fanfooty.com.au/index.php/topic,103046.0.html

I reckon Mumford, or Sauce (whichever works better for your byes)

barlowlove

Cheers mate, missed that one!
Mods please merge/delete haha

murrycurry

Thinking Blitz so I can get De Goey, no other downgrade targets at this stage really.

Sabretooth Tigers

 :)
Mummy for sure. Wasn't this pre season the best he has ever had. So now perhaps he'll go injury free. He's been in my side since late December and I see him being there until the end of the season. Ceers and the best of luck mate.   ;)

Desired7

Quote from: Grufflez on May 19, 2015, 03:31:17 PM
Quote from: Desired7 on May 19, 2015, 02:50:51 PM
I brought in Nic Nat for Jesse Hogan Last week hoping he would lift on his recent performances, but im still backing him to lft in a couple of week. i dont think his too far away from scoring some good scores soon so hopefully he comes good. was tossing up between him and mummy and saunce, but went the risky option and hoping it repays me throughout the rest of the season

Big mistake mate, most of us with him wish we could offload him, new ruck scoring system in SC is more reflecting on what he actually contributes now...

I have Maric and would take Blitz at 490k, becoming an important player to us at Geelong....until teams work out how to deal with him/ Sauce is a safe bet as well.

Doesn't look like such a big mistake now after mummy looks to miss next week and having two 140+ scores since bringing him in. So I can gladly say it was a genius move

smashbox


GCSkiwi

Still SMartin for me, don't know that I quite trust Blitz yet. Jacobs not a bad pick if the 40k makes a difference...