PLAYER X v PLAYER Y THREAD 2

[Deadly6]

Lambert or Knights? JS being the main concern

Lambert - expect him to get better as the season goes

[TomK]

Bench TMac or Newnes for Lever's 111?

[netterzzzz]

biggest liability maric vs hibberd

Will go to either armitage and hodge (if I trade hibberd)

Or Priddis and jacobs (if maric)

[BomberSam]

biggest liability maric vs hibberd

Will go to either armitage and hodge (if I trade hibberd)

Or Priddis and jacobs (if maric)

I don't think there is that much wrong with wither Hibberd or Maric. But if you have trades up your sleeve, I'd trade Maric, simply because Priddis and Jacobs should net more points than Armitage and Hodge, IMO.

[BomberSam]

Ward vs. Mundy?

[no eye deer]

Ward vs. Mundy?

Mundy easily if it doesn't cost youe elsewhere.

Sloane vs Selwood vs Sidey?

[ADEZ]

Have to decide now, do I field Steele (named on the ball) vs. Freo or Heeney (named in the FP) vs. Adelaide

[BomberSam]

Ward vs. Mundy?

Mundy easily if it doesn't cost youe elsewhere.

Sloane vs Selwood vs Sidey?

Selwood for me, I think he'll find his form of previous seasons on the run home, giving us a glimpse of that on the weekend with his 142 against the Giants. Sidebottom is definitely a nice POD option though, if that is what you are looking for, and you have the extra cash to spend. I wouldn't touch Sloane, too many question marks. He could get injured again, and I doubt he'll capture his early season form in the back end of the season. Hopefully his price stays down so we can all start him next season.

Have to decide now, do I field Steele (named on the ball) vs. Freo or Heeney (named in the FP) vs. Adelaide

Regardless of where he is named (means next to nothing), Steele for me. He has been consistent cover, ranging from 65-84. That sort of consistency, plus highs of 94 and 84 for an average of 77 in 5 games is very promising.

[H1bb3i2d]

Trade one out: Smith or Lumumba?

Trade one in: Sidebottom v Lewis v Sloane?

[PICCOLLO]

Trade one out: Smith or Lumumba?

Trade one in: Sidebottom v Lewis v Sloane?

Mumba has a handy m/f link but if you don't need the link then trade him.

Sloane>Lewis=Sidey

[Donnie Brasco]

Hannebery, Priddis, Mundy or Danger?

[no eye deer]

Bennell vs Jelwood to replace Wines?

[TomK]

Jelwood

[BomberSam]

Top 3 in order out of Sloane, Rocky, Lewis, Armitage and Sidebottom?

[colmullet]

Rocky, Sidebum, Lewis/armo