PLAYER X v PLAYER Y THREAD 2

[TheMoops]

Looking at it from the other way, who to keep out of K. Amon and T. Dumont?

Leaning towards keeping Amon as depth players could get a few more opportunities with Port being virtually out of the finals race.

[MC]

Goddard this week (cheap, but hasn't been as prominent recently)
VS
Adams next week (extra 70k or so, yet has been DOMINATING lately, averaging 115 last 5)

Each would only require 1 trade, leaving me with 3 - and the inclusion of one of these blokes pushes Ziebell/Motlop to the bench as mid/fwd cover. Was considering Lids, though he requires 2 trades and it would give me 4 tigers on field which i'm worried about.


PS - my worry with Adams is how the return of Greenwood effects him?

Not considering Jimmy?

DPP more valuable imo

[Jay]

Who goes to Ablett? Steven (been consistent, and as far I know is still healthy) or Beams (better scorer but injury issues)?

Have 6 trades left before my 2 this week. Which way should I go? :-X

[Bully]

Who goes to Ablett? Steven (been consistent, and as far I know is still healthy) or Beams (better scorer but injury issues)?

Have 6 trades left before my 2 this week. Which way should I go? :-X

I think Beams is the one who represents the bigger risk, Steven has a full bill of health so he deserves to stay.

[tkringle]

Who to punt for Ablett, Wines or Parker?

[Bully]

Who to punt for Ablett, Wines or Parker?

Wines has to go out of those 2, Parker has been pretty consistent for a couple of months now.

[tkringle]

Who to punt for Ablett, Wines or Parker?

Wines has to go out of those 2, Parker has been pretty consistent for a couple of months now.

Yeah think your right.. Midfield is Fyfe, Pendles, JPK, Ward, Mundy, Rocky, Parker and Wines. Wines being the obvious one to go for Ablett

[Donnie Brasco]

A.Pearce or Hamling?

who should I keep...

[Bully]

A.Pearce or Hamling?

who should I keep...

Pearce, there's no telling when Hamling will be back.

[Ricochet]

A.Pearce or Hamling?

who should I keep...

Pearce, there's no telling when Hamling will be back.

Pearce's days are numbered also. Although I'd love to see us try him up forward

[jfitty]

A.Pearce or Hamling?

who should I keep...

Keep Hamling, think his job security is pretty solid when healthy.

As Ric said, think Pearce's days are numbered

[Bully]

A.Pearce or Hamling?

who should I keep...

Pearce, there's no telling when Hamling will be back.

Pearce's days are numbered also. Although I'd love to see us try him up forward

Yeah, I see Johnson & Dawson are back a full fitness, maybe hang onto Hamling.

[TexR74]

Need to know real quick take Hodge's 140 or trust Ablett?

[BLBBLB]

Quick one:

Trade saad and lonie and my 350k in the bank for:

1: Goddard and Gablett and 100k or
2: vlaustin and zorko/lids/Mundy and ~20k

Still got 9 trades (yes was a little too conservative after past burnings) so can be aggressive now. Going for leagues and will need 2 defender upgrades to finish (if I dg saad and offload Brodie smith next week) in the next two weeks.

Go the "get ablett at all costs option" or the balanced approach?

[tkringle]

Lambert or Knights? JS being the main concern