PLAYER X v PLAYER Y THREAD 2

[Bully]

Knight v c Daniel

This is the decision I've been sweating on all week, think I'll go for Knight given he looks to have NVB's role for the rest of the season. He's a second year player so shouldn't tire as easily and he has that valuable DPP status. I remember at the combine Knight tested extraordinarily well for endurance so he's every chance to run out games at full tilt. Daniel also has a good tank but I can't see him spending as much time in the midfield. Tough choice but Knight for me.

[Raiden]

Glenn VS Maynard?

[Raiden]

Also Birchall vs Kelly (next week) vs Eski (D6)

[TexR74]

Trade out Lewis or Cripps for Gaz

[Deadly6]

Trade out Lewis or Cripps for Gaz

Cripps, he's done his job and you would think he'll start to tire at the back end of the season.

[no eye deer]

Knight or Maynard? I've already got Steele in the mids and Lambert fwd, but only Newnes to link with back anyway.

[enzedder]

@ Tex trade out Cripps.
@ Raiden get Birchall of those.

[Raiden]

@ Tex trade out Cripps.
@ Raiden get Birchall of those.

Thanks mate, leaning towards Birch also.

[no eye deer]

Picken vs Hodge?

[MC]

Picken vs Hodge?

Picken, since round 4 his lowest has been 89. SUPER consistent. Hodge could also get rested during Sc finals if the Hawks are cruising into September, which seems likely.

Glenn VS Maynard?

I would love an answer to this same question!

[no eye deer]

Picken vs Hodge?

Picken, since round 4 his lowest has been 89. SUPER consistent. Hodge could also get rested during Sc finals if the Hawks are cruising into September, which seems likely.

Yeh, I was thinking along the same lines.

[Bones Bombers]

If I trade out Jelwood I have $588k to spend.
The 2 guns I'm looking at are Joey Montagna and Sam Mitchell. Both older guys having great years.
Leaning towards Joey but any thoughts would be greatly appreciated.
Also is there someone else you would prefer?

[hawkboy80]

Picken vs Hodge?

Picken, since round 4 his lowest has been 89. SUPER consistent. Hodge could also get rested during Sc finals if the Hawks are cruising into September, which seems likely.

Glenn VS Maynard?

I would love an answer to this same question!

I think maynard will get only 2 or 3 games to see how he goes then probs will be dropped, too many ahead of him atm & pies have no need to rush him

[MC]

I'm leaning towards Maynard to use DPP with Mckenzie

[no eye deer]

I'm leaning towards Maynard to use DPP with Mckenzie

It would be nice if McKenzie could actually get a game.