PLAYER X v PLAYER Y THREAD 2

[tommy10]

Goddard vs Houli

[GCSkiwi]

Goddard vs Houli

Not really horses for courses there, is it a case of which to get this week, and the other another time? or what? Who's the fwd if you get Houli/who's the def if you get Goddard? Straight comparison I would say Goddard but it's not a case of two players, one position...

Would you go Hanners or Heppell and $40k

more help plz, everyone

coin flip. Gut says Hanners for me but depends how handy the 40k could be.

Um, personally i wouldn't go for either- i think dusty is a buy around mid 500 player, 600 is too much for anything less than a super premo.
If you can wait for a few weeks he is almost guaranteed to have a flat one or two and drop 50K (though i hope not :) )

Gawn has been playing super, i would be surprised if he can back it up for the rest of the season.
So far his scores have been against port/StK/Coll/Geel which all have comparatively weak rucks, his next four are- Wc Nic nat-  Ess ?? could be anyone or no-one -BL Martin -and then St kilda again.
If you got on early he was an great buy at 350, at 410 its a much tougher call. also still questions about his role in the club, and hasnt got a great history in regards to durabilty either, with a max of 13 games in a season.

Thanks mate :D

[Mark]

Would you go Hanners or Heppell and $40k

more help plz, everyone

coin flip. Gut says Hanners for me but depends how handy the 40k could be.

[/quote]

Cheers GCSkiwi,

That's the excact same reason im having trouble, My head is saying Hanners but I still have 1 upgrade next week in forwards to complete team and wonder if the $40k would help me out there.

The year its been ill prob end up picking the wrong one :)

[Capper]

Would you go Hanners or Heppell and $40k

more help plz, everyone

Hanners over Heppell

If you need coin do you have Sloane??

Goddard vs Houli

Goddard but i think Houli will get more ball with the positions they are currently playing

[Mark]

Would you go Hanners or Heppell and $40k

more help plz, everyone

Hanners over Heppell

If you need coin do you have Sloane??


Yeah mate got Sloane

[GCSkiwi]

Lambert vs Kavanagh

[Jackross10]

Someone please make my decision..:

Houli and Sloane vs Hibberd and Parker

[Ricochet]

Someone please make my decision..:

Houli and Sloane vs Hibberd and Parker

Houli and Sloane easily.

[Asparagus]

Houli v Simmo

[Big Mac]

Someone please make my decision..:

Houli and Sloane vs Hibberd and Parker

Houli and Sloane easily.

Houli v Simmo

[Mark]

Houli and Sloane mate..

And Simmo over Houli just mate..

Heppell + 40k or Hanners ???

[Asparagus]

Houli and Sloane mate..

And Simmo over Houli just mate..

Heppell + 40k or Hanners ???

Hanners just. As long as you don't have a few swans already (Parker JPK Titch)

[Asparagus]

Kavanagh vs Lambert. Getting in one of them this week.
But which?

[Mark]

Already have Kennedy in mids and TMitch in forwards..

Why u think tht would matter mate ?

[Asparagus]

Already have Kennedy in mids and TMitch in forwards..

Why u think tht would matter mate ?

Not a fan of having 3 or more Prems from the one team if I can help it.
Will prob get shouted down for this but I believe the 3 can't ALL go big in a game.
If you were thinking about sideway trading JPK later then go for it.