PLAYER X v PLAYER Y THREAD 2

[Mark]

Would you go Hanners or Heppell and $40k

[DoctorRush]

Would you go Hanners or Heppell and $40k

Hanners

[murrycurry]

Houli vs R. Murphy vs Picken ? getting rid of lumumba

[blackrose]

Houli vs R. Murphy vs Picken ? getting rid of lumumba

I went picken but I'm thinkin i should've gone houli

[netterzzzz]

mundy vs hanners vs beams vs priddis

[Thewizz71]

mundy vs hanners vs beams vs priddis

Beams- Lions starting to get some players back.

Amon v dummont?
Want to off load one for Lambert (get a m/f back in my mids)

[netterzzzz]

mundy vs hanners vs beams vs priddis

Beams- Lions starting to get some players back.

Amon v dummont?
Want to off load one for Lambert (get a m/f back in my mids)

Beams has had a minor shoulder problems but i suppose hes okay? still beams over hanners even with his price and BE?

[blackrose]

Smith +160k or Houli

[TexR74]

Beasly vs Edwards vs Steele to bring in this round

[Big Mac]

Would you go Hanners or Heppell and $40k

Hanners

Houli vs R. Murphy vs Picken ? getting rid of lumumba

Picken

mundy vs hanners vs beams vs priddis

Beams just ahead of Hanners imo

Smith +160k or Houli

Houli - can't rely on Smith to get back to his best

Beasly vs Edwards vs Steele to bring in this round

Steele

[Puppetry]

Who to TRADE OUT of Lonie and Krakouer?

[GCSkiwi]

Who to TRADE OUT of Lonie and Krakouer?

Depends if you need the player or not. Assuming it's not an issue, I would trade Lonie. Worth marginally more, lower average, only plus side is that he's playing this week and has a lower BE than Krak... But I think if I had to field one of them later in the year I'd rather Krak...


Not really an X vs Y, but is it worth paying 596k for Dusty now, or should I wait and hopefully in a few weeks he comes down? Low BE this week so he's still going up but could crash after that... Going to get Gawn for F7/R3 so could play him as F6 for a few weeks...

So, Dusty F6 now or Gawn F6 and wait?

[HotTiges]

Pittard vs Saad for a trade out..

Houli vs Picken trade in?

[johnoP]

Who to TRADE OUT of Lonie and Krakouer?

Depends if you need the player or not. Assuming it's not an issue, I would trade Lonie. Worth marginally more, lower average, only plus side is that he's playing this week and has a lower BE than Krak... But I think if I had to field one of them later in the year I'd rather Krak...


Not really an X vs Y, but is it worth paying 596k for Dusty now, or should I wait and hopefully in a few weeks he comes down? Low BE this week so he's still going up but could crash after that... Going to get Gawn for F7/R3 so could play him as F6 for a few weeks...

So, Dusty F6 now or Gawn F6 and wait?

Um, personally i wouldn't go for either- i think dusty is a buy around mid 500 player, 600 is too much for anything less than a super premo.
If you can wait for a few weeks he is almost guaranteed to have a flat one or two and drop 50K (though i hope not :) )

Gawn has been playing super, i would be surprised if he can back it up for the rest of the season.
So far his scores have been against port/StK/Coll/Geel which all have comparatively weak rucks, his next four are- Wc Nic nat-  Ess ?? could be anyone or no-one -BL Martin -and then St kilda again.
If you got on early he was an great buy at 350, at 410 its a much tougher call. also still questions about his role in the club, and hasnt got a great history in regards to durabilty either, with a max of 13 games in a season.

[Mark]

Would you go Hanners or Heppell and $40k

more help plz, everyone