PLAYER X v PLAYER Y THREAD 2

[ants]

Jelwood or Shiel? need a playing premo for r 11 and 12

Edit: Wines maybe??

jelwood is proven to goe well in the second half of the year!so him

trade out lever or mckenzie?

[tjeff]

Jelwood or Shiel? need a playing premo for r 11 and 12

Edit: Wines maybe??

jelwood is proven to goe well in the second half of the year!so him

trade out lever or mckenzie?

Probably McKenzie. Saints gained a few back from injury might see him struggle to get back in

[lucky]

Just wondering who will average higher from here on out regardless of bye and price:

beams vs priddis vs montagna?

[barlowlove]

Just wondering who will average higher from here on out regardless of bye and price:

beams vs priddis vs montagna?

I know you said regardless of bye, but if Beams scores 120 points in the next 2 rounds, that's 120 points you gain over when Priddis or Montagna have their bye in Rd 12 and 13. In order for Priddis or Montagna to make up that 120 points on Beams, they would need to out-average him by 10ppg from after the byes until the end of the year!

[plumdog millionaire]

Dahlhaus vs Shane Edwards

[TomK]

Dahlhaus vs Shane Edwards

Dahl

[Jimmykidd]

Simmo vs McDonald

[HotTiges]

Simmo vs McDonald

TMac..just getting back into SuperCoach form  8)

Mine is Ellis vs Lewis vs Sloane

[RaisyDaisy]

Hodge vs Houli +60k

Was going to bring in Hodge to complete my backline, but really starting to think I should get Houli +60k instead

[AaronKirk]

Hodge vs Houli +60k

Was going to bring in Hodge to complete my backline, but really starting to think I should get Houli +60k instead

I have thought about this one for 2 weeks. I will end up going with Hodge.

Hawthorn cannot afford to rest players. They need to win every match for the rest of the H+A season to try to get a home final.

Hodge has had 4 weeks off - 3 suspended and 1 with the bye - I cannot see him being rested. He has a higher ceiling than Houli, who is copping a lot more attention recently and his scoring has dropped.

Hodge for me.

[plumdog millionaire]

Amon v CEllis

[HotTiges]

Amon v CEllis

Ellis rated very highly by Hardwick. 1st rounder so will get games.. I expect him to miss a game or 2 due to his age but he is a fine player who can actually use the ball which is why he was recruited for..

[Thewizz71]

Dahl v Edwards - both look very similar this year (to replace Lonie)

[netterzzzz]

Newnes vs Saad vs Oxley
Pick one


and
Wingard vs JJK vs Smith vs Higgens
pick one

Thanks :)

[Big Mac]

Dahl v Edwards - both look very similar this year (to replace Lonie)

Bullies have an amazing draw from here

Newnes vs Saad vs Oxley
Pick one


and
Wingard vs JJK vs Smith vs Higgens
pick one

Thanks :)