PLAYER X v PLAYER Y THREAD 2

[Jimmykidd]

Save starting another thread

Last fwd upgrade! Already have gray, martin, swan, dahl, bont..

Kp fwds seem to be strong this year (rough, bud, gunston, reiwolt, kennedy) but I'm looking at Smith. Thoughts?

[RaisyDaisy]

Save starting another thread

Last fwd upgrade! Already have gray, martin, swan, dahl, bont..

Kp fwds seem to be strong this year (rough, bud, gunston, reiwolt, kennedy) but I'm looking at Smith. Thoughts?

Reckon Goddard, Lids, Buddy or Titch are better options

[jfitty]

Save starting another thread

Last fwd upgrade! Already have gray, martin, swan, dahl, bont..

Kp fwds seem to be strong this year (rough, bud, gunston, reiwolt, kennedy) but I'm looking at Smith. Thoughts?

Reckon Goddard, Lids, Buddy or Titch are better options

Yep agree with RD, probably in that order too.

However considering the players you already have, Buddy could be a good one to throw in there. Will give you some monster scores and has VC potential

[Mark]

Has McDonald had his good run and now on the way down....

Av just 80 least 3 weeks.

Would it be better getting in Houli, Hibberd (much cheaper), or even McGovern...

Want to upgrade Tosh to someone..

Already have Shaw, Gibson, Birch, Rance plus the usual rookies Saad, Oxley, Lever

[dicko_]

Has McDonald had his good run and now on the way down....
Av just 80 least 3 weeks.
Would it be better getting in Houli, Hibberd (much cheaper), or even McGovern...
Want to upgrade Tosh to someone..
Already have Shaw, Gibson, Birch, Rance plus the usual rookies Saad, Oxley, Lever

Was never keen on McDonald, or on any key position players in general.
I've had Houli all year and still don't know what to make of him; sometimes he dominates, and then other games is completely unsighted for entire quarters, or even longer. His scoring doesn't seem to be linked to having a particular opponent either, but on the whole he has been really good.

Value seems the way to go in the backs, so either Hibberd, or Brodie Smith if he can get over his concussion.

[Jimmykidd]

Save starting another thread

Last fwd upgrade! Already have gray, martin, swan, dahl, bont..

Kp fwds seem to be strong this year (rough, bud, gunston, reiwolt, kennedy) but I'm looking at Smith. Thoughts?

Reckon Goddard, Lids, Buddy or Titch are better options

Yep agree with RD, probably in that order too.

However considering the players you already have, Buddy could be a good one to throw in there. Will give you some monster scores and has VC potential

Titch I like.. Worth jumping on? was scared of his JS but seems to be cemented in that team now. Would be a bit more consistent than buddy. Lids the only other i'd consider but very pricey!

[Jackross10]

Shiel vs Wines

[Jimmykidd]

Shiel vs Wines

I want both haha. Unfortunately can't get wines this week as i had planned.

I'd go Wines, but that's a tought one.

[Big Mac]

Shiel vs Wines

Shiel

[MC]

Shiel vs Ward?

[Jimmykidd]

Shiel vs Ward?

Shiel. Ward got boosted up by his 175. wont do that every week.

[Mark]

Has McDonald had his good run and now on the way down....

Av just 80 least 3 weeks.

Would it be better getting in Houli, Hibberd (much cheaper), or even McGovern...

Want to upgrade Tosh to someone..

Already have Shaw, Gibson, Birch, Rance plus the usual rookies Saad, Oxley, Lever

More help plz

[Jay]

Shiel vs Ward?

Shiel. Ward got boosted up by his 175. wont do that every week.

Ward. Proven gun. Was priced at 600k @ beginning of the year for a reason.

[Brookesy]

Shiel vs Ward?

Shiel. Ward got boosted up by his 175. wont do that every week.

Ward. Proven gun. Was priced at 600k @ beginning of the year for a reason.

What about Wines v Ward?

[Jay]

Shiel vs Ward?

Shiel. Ward got boosted up by his 175. wont do that every week.

Ward. Proven gun. Was priced at 600k @ beginning of the year for a reason.

What about Wines v Ward?

Now that's a tough one, I'm considered the same, but this is how I arrived at sticking with Ward.

Wines obviously had the sub affected game where only played 65% of game time. He was on 76 at the time, so if we presume he played his average amount of game time, his score would have been approximately 96 points. Taking that into his average, he's at about 113 for the year. Funnily enough, the same as Ward averaged in 2014.

It's a toss of a coin. The question is, does Wines being 20k cheaper make up for the fact that Ward averaged 113 over 20 games last season whereas Wines has only done it for 6? I don't think so.