ROUND 7 TRADES

[Big Mac]

Thinking of going Vanders + Hogan ---> Goddard + Mckenzie

Playing 3 rookies in the fwd line has been killing me

Would need Lever to perform for a downgrade next week though

[Mat0369]

McIntosh still has a gettable BE so I am thinking Vanders to McKenzi (like I need more cash) and Hogan to Gray.

[Fid]

Seriously considering rage trading NicNat to Martin!!!

You don't consider Sauce Jacobs an option ($100,000 cheaper)

[tkringle]

Thinking Vanders to McKenzie (vanders has topped out with a 61 BE).

With the second one I will be trading out Hogan, however not sure whether to strengthen my rucks or forward line? Will be brining in one of Mitchell (FWD) or Sauce/Martin into the ruck (via Belly DPP)

Current Mid/ruck/forward lines are:

Mids: Fyfe, Pendles, JPK, Selwood, Gray, Griffen, Cripps, Miller (Vanders, CEY, Krak)
Ruck: Goldy, Belly (Read)
Forwards: Martin, Goddard, Swan, Franklin, Tarrant, Clarke (Lonie, Hogan)

If I bring in Mitchell that will be my last forward upgrade as I have Gray in the mids who I will be swinging back forward in the coming weeks. $165K in the bank, 23 trades remaining

Thoughts?

[Holden the ball]

hold mcintosh i reckon for some reason his BE is 33

[H1bb3i2d]

hold mcintosh i reckon for some reason his BE is 33

Is there a BE thread anywhere yet?

[IntegralX]

I've done this:

Heeney--->Glenn
Vanders---> T. Mitchell (will swing to fwds at some point)

Next week:

McIntosh--->Lever
Hogan/CEY--->???

CEY will go if he doesn't get in/has a setback week after next.

[RaisyDaisy]

I'm really puzzled about which way I should go

I've decided to pass on Mitchell simply because I cant trust his JS

Not really interested in Barlow or Parker, considering Sloane and Rocky bottom out next week

I was going to trade Heeney to McKenzie then turn Cripps into JPK, leaving me with 90k so that next week I could trade Vanders to Rocky in a single trade, so 3 trades total gets me JPK and Rocky

Looking at my team however, Heeney, Tosh, Vanders and Hogan seem to be the main 4 I should be looking to trade out, and not Cripps considering he is scoring so well, but the problem I have is that by trading any combination of those 4 requires a 4th trade to get JPK and Rocky, and the bigger concern is that besides McKenzie I don't see any other downgrade targets for next week

Lever and Stretch are the only two I see, and I'm not confident on either of there's JS

If I go ahead with Heeney to McKenzie, Cripps to JPK and Vanders to Rocky next week, I'm still left with Hogan and Tosh. Maybe's that's not too bad, they wont drop heaps of cash and I can just hold them until better downgrade options appear and they'd be on  the bench anyway, but trading out Cripps does feel odd based on his scoring

90k prob wont be enough to do Vanders to Rocky now after Vanders poor round, so I guess I'll have to make another downgrade with that option anyway too :(

Argh! Advice and suggestions would be very appreciate :)

[lucky]

anyone noticed shane edwards is avging 108 this year, should he be considered?

[Jimmykidd]

Kmac to McKenzie all but locked. Although I do still have nvb. Maybe nvb instead?

Also considering rich to tmitchell. Cost me 4k and he seems to be going great. Heeney out now will surely help his js. Thoughts?

[FactHunt]

anyone noticed shane edwards is avging 108 this year, should he be considered?

No. But no he shouldn't.

[Mat0369]

Hogan has a BE of 77 playing the Hawks, he has to go, Vanders has a BE of 61, he is in that maybe he has to go range, Tosh has a BE of 33, I think he stays. Cripps has a BE of 68 this week and is playing the Giants he could score pretty decently and also makes the most sense to hold another week

[RaisyDaisy]

Hogan has a BE of 77 playing the Hawks, he has to go, Vanders has a BE of 61, he is in that maybe he has to go range, Tosh has a BE of 33, I think he stays. Cripps has a BE of 68 this week and is playing the Giants he could score pretty decently and also makes the most sense to hold another week

Disagree about Hogan

He can easily score 60 vs the Hawks, and after this week his BE will be low again and he will continue to make some money

In terms of not making much more cash, Vanders and the injured Heeney are my two, but I'm 10k short of getting JPK for them which is very annoying, so one of them will have to stay a bit longer

[Asparagus]

hold mcintosh i reckon for some reason his BE is 33

Is there a BE thread anywhere yet?

Yep on twitter

KMac BE 33

[Gigantor]

I'm really puzzled about which way I should go

I've decided to pass on Mitchell simply because I cant trust his JS

Not really interested in Barlow or Parker, considering Sloane and Rocky bottom out next week

I was going to trade Heeney to McKenzie then turn Cripps into JPK, leaving me with 90k so that next week I could trade Vanders to Rocky in a single trade, so 3 trades total gets me JPK and Rocky

Looking at my team however, Heeney, Tosh, Vanders and Hogan seem to be the main 4 I should be looking to trade out, and not Cripps considering he is scoring so well, but the problem I have is that by trading any combination of those 4 requires a 4th trade to get JPK and Rocky, and the bigger concern is that besides McKenzie I don't see any other downgrade targets for next week

Lever and Stretch are the only two I see, and I'm not confident on either of there's JS

If I go ahead with Heeney to McKenzie, Cripps to JPK and Vanders to Rocky next week, I'm still left with Hogan and Tosh. Maybe's that's not too bad, they wont drop heaps of cash and I can just hold them until better downgrade options appear and they'd be on  the bench anyway, but trading out Cripps does feel odd based on his scoring

90k prob wont be enough to do Vanders to Rocky now after Vanders poor round, so I guess I'll have to make another downgrade with that option anyway too :(

Argh! Advice and suggestions would be very appreciate :)

I would try very hard to keep Cripps for the byes, he along with CEY will be gold in rd12+13

I'm going Stretch but iirc you already have Glenn so having both is too risky.

What about Hogan>Goddard Heeney>Mckenzie then Vanders to Rocky
I know that means JPK is going to go up in price but you cant always win:)