Dont yet have Pendles..

[Elcapitano]

i know Pendles is a Must have come years end, but at this stage im considering bringing in JPK just because he seems to have bottomed out and im thinking Pendles will be around this price for a few rounds.

What would you do:

Option 1. JPK + $90k (for sooner upgrades)
Option 2. Pendlebury ASAP as he is a must??

Current Mids : Fyfe, Selwood, Danger, Bonts, Griffen, & usual Mids
Fwds: Swan, Bennell, Martin, Ryder, Salem, Tarrant (Clark, Lonie)

Trading out Salem switching Bonts to Fwds...

[Southstorm]

I'd take the extra cash mate.

[BomberSam]

i know Pendles is a Must have come years end, but at this stage im considering bringing in JPK just because he seems to have bottomed out and im thinking Pendles will be around this price for a few rounds.

What would you do:

Option 1. JPK + $90k (for sooner upgrades)
Option 2. Pendlebury ASAP as he is a must??

Current Mids : Fyfe, Selwood, Danger, Bonts, Griffen, & usual Mids
Fwds: Swan, Bennell, Martin, Ryder, Salem, Tarrant (Clark, Lonie)

I have the same predicament and have taken JPK, for what it's worth. I hope to have him in the next 3-4 weeks. I just hope he doesn't tear it up in that time.

[Wanderer]

Pendles scores first 4 weeks before his 158 against Carlton = 113, 126, 107, 119.

Just looks a little low for $634K and I wouldn't read too much into Carlton score because they rolled over and had a 1st game rookie play on him.

[Capper]

I would take Pendles

[LordSneeze]

Not having Pendles has lost me 5 matches this season.
Not having JPK has won me 5
Im trading him in.

[AlexIsOnFire]

I've picked JPK this week.

Pendles will come in later

[no eye deer]

Not having Pendles has lost me 5 matches this season.
Not having JPK has won me 5
Im trading him in.

Please explain how you've won five and lost five by round five? :o

[LordSneeze]

Not having Pendles has lost me 5 matches this season.
Not having JPK has won me 5
Im trading him in.

Please explain how you've won five and lost five by round five? :o

Im in 7 leagues.

Ive actually decided to trade both in this week.

[j959]

to answer your question posed ...

well what are you doing??
just get him in!  :o   ;)

aka ... 'no Pendles?? = you're doin it wrong!'    ;)

[BomberSam]

Not having Pendles has lost me 5 matches this season.
Not having JPK has won me 5
Im trading him in.

So, all 5 games you lost due to not having Pendles were in round 5.

And all 5 games you won due to not having JPK were in round 3?

[LordSneeze]

Not having Pendles has lost me 5 matches this season.
Not having JPK has won me 5
Im trading him in.

So, all 5 games you lost due to not having Pendles were in round 5.

And all 5 games you won due to not having JPK were in round 3?

The Pendles one was all 5, the JPK one was 3 in round 3 and 2 times when  my opponent had him as captain when he scored 110 and I had Fyfe as C

[BomberSam]

Not having Pendles has lost me 5 matches this season.
Not having JPK has won me 5
Im trading him in.

So, all 5 games you lost due to not having Pendles were in round 5.

And all 5 games you won due to not having JPK were in round 3?

The Pendles one was all 5, the JPK one was 3 in round 3 and 2 times when  my opponent had him as captain when he scored 110 and I had Fyfe as C

What did Fyfe score in that round? Can't have been much in it!

[LordSneeze]

Not having Pendles has lost me 5 matches this season.
Not having JPK has won me 5
Im trading him in.

So, all 5 games you lost due to not having Pendles were in round 5.

And all 5 games you won due to not having JPK were in round 3?

The Pendles one was all 5, the JPK one was 3 in round 3 and 2 times when  my opponent had him as captain when he scored 110 and I had Fyfe as C

What did Fyfe score in that round? Can't have been much in it!

Cant remember off the top of my head, but I wont by only 15-20 points in one and 2 points in another.
It was in round 4

[Mark]

Pendels limping most of the night with ankle...doesn't look 100%

Watch this space maybe..