Sam's Team thread

[Samsturmfels]

I have 935k to spend on 2 players because im trading hunt and Salem)
- 1 defender and 1 forward or Midfielder

Could u guys please help me out


i have
Shaw, Gibson, HL. Oxley, Newnes, Hunt (saad, McIntosh)
Fyfe, Pendles, Sloane, Beams, Griffen, VB, Cripps, CEY (krak, Brayshaw)
Goldy, Belly (Reid)
Gray, Martin, Swan, Hogan, Tarrant, Clark (Lonie, Salem)

which 2 players should i trade in?

[Big Mac]

Not sure you have enough $$ to get in two good players unless you go for cheapies like Barlow/Parker/Ziebell

Maybe bring McDonald in for Hunt since his BE is massive, and then save the rest for next week?

[Samsturmfels]

Not sure you have enough $$ to get in two good players unless you go for cheapies like Barlow/Parker/Ziebell

Maybe bring McDonald in for Hunt since his BE is massive, and then save the rest for next week?

ive considered that,but id love to get 2 keepers in this week

[Samsturmfels]

Bump

[Big Mac]

Bump

Ziebell and McDonald if you have to

[GCSkiwi]

Bump

Not at you alone, but when threads don't attract much attention it's generally due to one of two things that I've noticed.

1) People asking mission impossible: eg "Guys, I have 1 trade and 30k in the bank, ranked 213,000th, how do I win supercoach?"
2) People asking for the team that fanfooty built, eg "here is my team, what should I do with it?"

You're falling into the latter category. Try to suggest some options of what and why you're thinking, eg "I'm thinking Hunt for Rance and Salem for Bont, both have started the season really well and looks like a good time to grab them"

That at least generates some discussion, because people might come back with "I'm worried about whether Bont will turn out to be a keeper, could get tired and taper off by the end of the season, perhaps grab Rioli instead", then someone else comments "twang go the hamstrings".

In your case, you're asking for 2 keepers for 935k, which is also a bit of a mission impossible - keeper mids are generally >550k, fwds generally >500k and defenders >450k. Hence we're all always bargain watching.

Give some more and you may receive some more...

[Big Mac]

Bump

Not at you alone, but when threads don't attract much attention it's generally due to one of two things that I've noticed.

1) People asking mission impossible: eg "Guys, I have 1 trade and 30k in the bank, ranked 213,000th, how do I win supercoach?"
2) People asking for the team that fanfooty built, eg "here is my team, what should I do with it?"

You're falling into the latter category. Try to suggest some options of what and why you're thinking, eg "I'm thinking Hunt for Rance and Salem for Bont, both have started the season really well and looks like a good time to grab them"

That at least generates some discussion, because people might come back with "I'm worried about whether Bont will turn out to be a keeper, could get tired and taper off by the end of the season, perhaps grab Rioli instead", then someone else comments "twang go the hamstrings".

In your case, you're asking for 2 keepers for 935k, which is also a bit of a mission impossible - keeper mids are generally >550k, fwds generally >500k and defenders >450k. Hence we're all always bargain watching.

Give some more and you may receive some more...

Good points - this is too expensive though. There definitely is some mission impossible involved here haha

[GCSkiwi]

haha I didn't do the sums it was purely names for an example :P

[Samsturmfels]

I have some of my ideas in the poll

[crowls]

I have some of my ideas in the poll

trade in Goddard in forwards and hold Hunt for Smith or Simpson upgrade in another week or two
Strengthen forwards and get rewards for holding off on dropping backline prems

[GCSkiwi]

I have some of my ideas in the poll

... And no discussion on why you're thinking about picking them, you just want other people to tell you who to get...

2) People asking for the team that fanfooty built, eg "here is my team, what should I do with it?"

[Carn]

Not sure you have enough $$ to get in two good players unless you go for cheapies like Barlow/Parker/Ziebell

Maybe bring McDonald in for Hunt since his BE is massive, and then save the rest for next week?

+1 agree with this.

[Samsturmfels]

i have 24 trades left, 295k in the bank
Shaw, Gibson, HL. Oxley, Newnes, saad (hunt, McIntosh)
Fyfe, Pendles, Sloane, Beams, Griffen, VB, Cripps, Heeney (krak, Brayshaw, glenn)
Goldy, Belly (Reid)
Gray, Martin, Goddard, Swan, Clark, Tarrant (Lonie, Hogan)

Last week i traded in Goddard and Glenn for CEY and Salem

I was originally intending to trade
this week:
Heeney to JPK
hunt to Mckenzie
next week
McIntosh to Lever
Hogan to premo ruck man


but now i have injuries to Sloane, Heeney, Saad and Gleen

Which set of trades should i make this week?
1) Sloane to Midpremo, Heeney to mid premo, field Hunt or McIntosh
2)Hunt-Mckenzie, Heeney to Mid premo, keep Sloane
3) Heeney to Mckenzie (saad to the mids)then sloane to midpremo

[Big Mac]

Hunt to Mckenzie, Heeney to JPK

[hawkboy80]

option 2