SC Draft trade advice

[TexR74]

The draft format is really good, and i haven't seen anything on advice for potential trades in this format. I need help with this one.

Is it worth chasing Rocky with this trade?

Watson ==> Rocky
Hodge  ==> Murphy

The guy i'm offering it to is a diehard bomber as well...

[makita]

na i wouldn't do that i don't think, pretty even. I don't think Rocky will be back to his 130 year and Jobe could well be back to his

120s with the weight off his shoulders. Hodge playing through the mids is handy and Bob and the WB should slow down at some

point.

If he is a die hard bombers fan just offer him Jobe straight up for Rocky. Or if u have a lesser player on ur bench who is decent

throw him in as well as a little sweetener.

[GCSkiwi]

Bob or Marc Murphy? Assume Marc? If it's Bob then straight up no. If Marc, when they're on form I reckon Rocky and Murphy are better than Jobe and Hodge but I think that could take some time with Rocky. I would still say no. At this point in time Jobe and Hodge are performing better than Rocky and Murphy so it makes no sense for you to give them up.

[TexR74]

What about this one?



Hodge, Luke  [DEF, MID]
Mundy, David  [MID]
Maric, Ivan  [RUC]

FOR

Selwood, Joel  [MID]
Shaw, Heath  [DEF]
Naitanui, Nic  [RUC]

[eg6914]

no.2 is easily the winner

[TexR74]

no.2 is easily the winner

Which is no. 2?

[H1bb3i2d]

no.2 is easily the winner

Which is no. 2?

What about this one?



Hodge, Luke  [DEF, MID]
Mundy, David  [MID]
Maric, Ivan  [RUC]

FOR

Selwood, Joel  [MID]
Shaw, Heath  [DEF]
Naitanui, Nic  [RUC]

This?

[MC]

Yeah holy crap 2nd option dominates.

Shaw > Hodge
Selwood > Mundy
NN > Ivan

3-0 demolition!

[TexR74]

Is Hurley worth looking at?

[makita]

Is Hurley worth looking at?

As a waiver claim yes. As part of a trade, depends who for.

[_wato]

My trades this year so far hahaha

Selwood + Bartel -> Fyfe, Franklin
Mundy + Cotch -> Jobe and Ward
Bartel -> Bennell
Lobbe -> Nic Nat
Walker -> Enright
Crouch -> Jones
Then will pick up Bartel in free agency again hahahaha

LOL at my league

Team is this too
Shaw, Hibberd, Taylor, Enright, Hurn (Newnes)
Fyfe, Sidebottom, Rockliff, Ward, Watson, Murphy, Gibbs (Jones)
Goldstein (NN)
Gray, Franklin, Dahlhaus, Bennell, Ziebell (Bartel)

[TexR74]

Is Hurley worth looking at?

As a waiver claim yes. As part of a trade, depends who for.

Hodge & Jones for Hurley and Parker/Hanneberry/Priddis, cant decide which but I'm leaning towards Parker

[GCSkiwi]

My trades this year so far hahaha

Selwood + Bartel -> Fyfe, Franklin
Mundy + Cotch -> Jobe and Ward
Bartel -> Bennell
Lobbe -> Nic Nat
Walker -> Enright
Crouch -> Jones
Then will pick up Bartel in free agency again hahahaha

LOL at my league

Team is this too
Shaw, Hibberd, Taylor, Enright, Hurn (Newnes)
Fyfe, Sidebottom, Rockliff, Ward, Watson, Murphy, Gibbs (Jones)
Goldstein (NN)
Gray, Franklin, Dahlhaus, Bennell, Ziebell (Bartel)

I don't really understand draft that well, but is it fair to say you're murdering other teams? I guess with Rocky and Sidey out that's a pain but that looks like a pretty dominant squad...

[_wato]

I don't really understand draft that well, but is it fair to say you're murdering other teams? I guess with Rocky and Sidey out that's a pain but that looks like a pretty dominant squad...

Yeah Rocky and Sidey both out did hurt, lost two games with them both out and having to cop a donut in the midfield (didn't wanna trade, nobody good to get)

Also was the week where Ziebell scored 4 and Bartel scored 5 hahaha, so not the greatest start unfortunately but should go undefeated as of now

[MC]

Righto boys, I have Kade Kolodashnij in my draft squad, with the option of getting in Wright/Johanissen/Butler/Grundy

What do you think? Hold or punt?