Main Menu

SJ

Started by kilbluff1985, April 26, 2015, 10:13:22 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

_wato


timtim

He'd make a good M9 if he drops below $400k. But surely you have bigger problems and better use of cash?

H1bb3i2d

Do I get him over Parker or Barlow though? Being this early in the season and so many games remaining, I'd probably be looking at bringing in a more durable player that SJ, and these 2 are much more reliable. But it will all depend on how low they go and when they bottom out/which rookies have fattened up/do I have to prioritise trades elsewhere. All are on the watchlist for sure

Cotch-9

Quote from: H1bb3i2d on April 29, 2015, 07:56:59 PM
Do I get him over Parker or Barlow though? Being this early in the season and so many games remaining, I'd probably be looking at bringing in a more durable player that SJ, and these 2 are much more reliable. But it will all depend on how low they go and when they bottom out/which rookies have fattened up/do I have to prioritise trades elsewhere. All are on the watchlist for sure

You could Kieren Jack to that list priced at $511,100 with a breakeven of 182

Grufflez

Quote from: Cotch-9 on April 29, 2015, 08:10:35 PM
Quote from: H1bb3i2d on April 29, 2015, 07:56:59 PM
Do I get him over Parker or Barlow though? Being this early in the season and so many games remaining, I'd probably be looking at bringing in a more durable player that SJ, and these 2 are much more reliable. But it will all depend on how low they go and when they bottom out/which rookies have fattened up/do I have to prioritise trades elsewhere. All are on the watchlist for sure

You could Kieren Jack to that list priced at $511,100 with a breakeven of 182

Other than JPK Sydney mids are a nightmare to pick...not sure why people don't mention this more but a different Sydney mid seems to fire each year and sometimes each month and even each game!

HotTiges

Quote from: Cotch-9 on April 29, 2015, 08:10:35 PM
Quote from: H1bb3i2d on April 29, 2015, 07:56:59 PM
Do I get him over Parker or Barlow though? Being this early in the season and so many games remaining, I'd probably be looking at bringing in a more durable player that SJ, and these 2 are much more reliable. But it will all depend on how low they go and when they bottom out/which rookies have fattened up/do I have to prioritise trades elsewhere. All are on the watchlist for sure

You could Kieren Jack to that list priced at $511,100 with a breakeven of 182
Had Jack last season.. very ordinary as soon as I picked him up after round 12 or so

kilbluff1985

so tempting for 430k straight swap for Rich even if he turn out to be a M9

shouldn't get much attention from Pies and might turn up for a Friday night game

kilbluff1985

bloody hell

he so coming in this week

HotTiges

Yep SJ looked back in form.Mitch Duncan looks great value

H1bb3i2d

$420k now..... wow. Think I'll jump on if I have a spare trade, even if I end up dumping him for Ablett or leaving him at M9. If he can fill that M8 spot though he's a steal

RaisyDaisy

Think I'd rather Rocky in 2 weeks for the same price, although for a M9 it's a bargain

_wato

Yeah M9 bargain, doubt I'll pick him up but

tkringle

Wouldn't expect either to average 105+ By seasons end, so why would you pick them in the midfield?

FactHunt

Quote from: tkringle on May 08, 2015, 10:52:17 PM
Wouldn't expect either to average 105+ By seasons end, so why would you pick them in the midfield?

Rocky could easy go 115 ave here on out if fit (maybe give him a couple of weeks)... for what you could get him in for- it would be madness not to consider him

tkringle

#29
Quote from: FactHunt on May 08, 2015, 10:57:37 PM
Quote from: tkringle on May 08, 2015, 10:52:17 PM
Wouldn't expect either to average 105+ By seasons end, so why would you pick them in the midfield?

Rocky could easy go 115 ave here on out if fit (maybe give him a couple of weeks)... for what you could get him in for- it would be madness not to consider him

Agreed on Rock. Sorry, I was referring to the comments about SJ and Duncan being value... cant see how they are value. For midfield at this stage you have to be thinking any trade is for cash generation or keeper. Is 100-105 average a keeper at M7-M8? has not been any other year, not sure why it would be now