ROUND 5 TRADES

[Elcapitano]

With Heeney being dropped.... Plus a rolling score of 7 AND... now TMitch playing (if he goes big you think he'll will cement a spot)

Do we now trade Heeney over NVB?

Also thinking M Crouch is included... This could have a further effect on NVB like Thompson has done?

Geeeez... What to Do....

[Mat0369]

So I had my trades done.... NVB for Krak and Saad for Tarrant...

Now with Heeney out I'm leaning towards keeping NVB and moving Heeney.

Is this what others are doing?

I was thinking the same but he might not hit his BE. Clark is the other to consider as well with foot soreness. I think I might hold Heeney because he still has a break even that is gettable and I might need him for loophole purposes next week since the Cats play the Pies on Friday night if he misses a couple

[cortez]

It's quite easy in my opinion, you want money makers, Heeney and Clark are injured therefore not making money, cya later...

[kilbluff1985]

It's quite easy in my opinion, you want money makers, Heeney and Clark are injured therefore not making money, cya later...

it's not that simple they still have money to make

for example i can trade Newton or Heeney to Krak

i'm choosing to trade Newton as i don't think he has much more money to make and don't expect him to score well vs Freo

[Big Mac]

It's quite easy in my opinion, you want money makers, Heeney and Clark are injured therefore not making money, cya later...

Clark could just as easily come in next week and kick 6

No one knows the true extent of the injury

[JC]

Heeney, NVB or Cockatoo out for Krak. I can't make up my mind

[whynot102]

NCB and bank the cash

[batt]

I don't think Clark is worth trading under any circumstance.  Cats won't be this bad all season so he'll get better delivery.  Only needs 1 big score to get to 350k.

Bone bruising shouldn't change your decision.

[pies124]

Ive traded Lamb to tarant, im thinking about Heeney to Krakour but ive already used three trades so this will only leave me with 25 trades, what are your guys thoughts?

[AaronKirk]

Heeney has the highest BE of my midfield rookies and now is out. No brainer to trade him to Tarrant via krak DPP.

I was going to upgrade one of Salem or Newton to Ward this week. Now Clark is out I may as well trade him for Ward and let the other 2 make cash. There is no guarantee he will be back next week.

Even if it is the other foot and not the one he had problems with at Melbourne he has a history of injury concerns and I have no other problems at the moment with my team.

[AaronKirk]

Bone bruising shouldn't change your decision.

Leigh Montagna has bone bruising and will miss for the 4th week in a row. It doesn't go away quickly.

[Judd Magic]

Bone bruising shouldn't change your decision.

Leigh Montagna has bone bruising and will miss for the 4th week in a row. It doesn't go away quickly.

Clarks foot bruising has been stated as "minor" though.

Big difference to Montagna.

[ryanbob0357]

Im considering using Clarks injury as a way to get in Tarrant, as well as Heeney to Krakour, thoughts?

[Mat0369]

Clark is also a bigger guy, all that weight on your feet can mean it takes longer to recover

[Mat0369]

In terms of trades I am considering one of 3

1. NVB and Heeney to Krak and Taz (trade planned earlier in the week)

2. NVB and Clark to Krak and Taz

3. Clark and Heeney to Krak and Taz

Each have their pros and cons and I have gone through them in my team thread