ROUND 5 TRADES

[Mark]

Anyone thinking about Newnes to Hibberd ???

I know its kind of a waste of trade but can see the positives..

[Jackross10]

Anyone thinking about Newnes to Hibberd ???

I know its kind of a waste of trade but can see the positives..

Don't think it's worth it. Hibberd has only scored 30 odd more points than Newnes. Maybe wait a few more weeks, defence isn't where the points are at this year, seems to be well down. Reassess in a few weeks

[Samsturmfels]

Anyone thinking about Newnes to Hibberd ???

I know its kind of a waste of trade but can see the positives..

Yes I am defiantly considering getting him in. Hes usually a consistent good scorer. Compared to Newnes who is costing my team at the moment

[cortez]

Going to make 2 our of these 3

Goodes > Kelly
Heeney > Krakouer
Salem > Tarrant/ Krakouer

If I go Goodes to Kelly the other trade will be Salem > Krakouer
If I go Heeney to Krakouer the other trade will be Salem to Tarrant.

[Blues Blues Blues]

anyone considering trading Gray out for Tarrant?

Have you considered quiting Supercoach?? I think that would be a better option

love it. 

Hahahaha just made me laugh out loud in my meeting  ;D

BOOM! Haha, nice. Sweet, simple and to the point

[tommy10]

Going to make 2 our of these 3

Goodes > Kelly
Heeney > Krakouer
Salem > Tarrant/ Krakouer

If I go Goodes to Kelly the other trade will be Salem > Krakouer
If I go Heeney to Krakouer the other trade will be Salem to Tarrant.

Heeney and Salem to Krak and Tarrant cortez

[Gigantor]

Brayshaw or Heeney for Krak? (I don't have NVB)
Really struggling to split them, Melbourne have a tough draw coming up but I think Brayshaw would be a good slow burner up to his rd13 bye. Heeney still could jump a bit in a few weeks once the 7 is out but I'm still concerned he could cop a sub.

[Ricochet]

Brayshaw or Heeney for Krak? (I don't have NVB)
Really struggling to split them, Melbourne have a tough draw coming up but I think Brayshaw would be a good slow burner up to his rd13 bye. Heeney still could jump a bit in a few weeks once the 7 is out but I'm still concerned he could cop a sub.

You'd be looking to upgrade/downgrade both in the next 2-3 weeks so I'd go Heeney first and then Brayshaw when he's ripe

[LordSneeze]

Brayshaw or Heeney for Krak? (I don't have NVB)
Really struggling to split them, Melbourne have a tough draw coming up but I think Brayshaw would be a good slow burner up to his rd13 bye. Heeney still could jump a bit in a few weeks once the 7 is out but I'm still concerned he could cop a sub.

You'd be looking to upgrade/downgrade both in the next 2-3 weeks so I'd go Heeney first and then Brayshaw when he's ripe

Heeney will have a roling 7 in his average. Brayshaw has shown he can score well and is way more likely to go +100.

[Asparagus]

Up fwd I have ASaad and Lonie. I am doing Saad>Tarrant.

In the Mids I have Heeney, Clem Smith, Miller, CEY and VDBerg.

Do I do CSmith or Heeney for Krakour???

Heeney gives me more cash in bank but has good JS.

CSmith is not playing and gives me LESS cash in bank BUT gives me a loophole option.

CSmith or Heeney?????

[Mat0369]

Smith. He won't be back for a long time and you probably have an option at R3 for loop holing anyway

[Woppa15]

lamb > tarrant
heeney/NVB > krak

Unsure of who to drop out of Heeney and NVB, guess it depends on Heeney's injury
NVB has looked average since Thompson has come back in, plus he'll have a higher BE than Heeney

I'm also tossing up between which one to get rid of
Breakevens:
Heeney  35
NVB  64

I'm dropping NVB this week

Tough game and might actually drop money

Heeney should be good for 60+ against the doggies though

NVB output has suffered since Thompson has come back and will probably suffer further whenever the Crouch boys are back also. He seems to have plateaued.

Heeney had a bad game yes but that 7 will role out in 2 weeks and he will continue to make money. Also his ankle is reportedly fine.

If it were my decision is keep Heeney.

[Rusty00]

Anyone thinking about Newnes to Hibberd ???

I know its kind of a waste of trade but can see the positives..

I've thought about it, but am getting on the Krak and Tarrant bubbles this week so probably won't happen.

[maygs]

I can trade Goodes -> Krak (via a subs with Pearce) OR Lamb - > Krak

Which would you all suggest is the better option?

[Grufflez]

Anyone thinking about Newnes to Hibberd ???

I know its kind of a waste of trade but can see the positives..

I wanna do it but can't waste the trade.
I feel that i will be walking around in unclean jocks all year due to two turds i've nicnamed Newnes & Lumumba that i'll never find the time to wash out.