ROUND 5 TRADES

[kilbluff1985]

this guy reckons he is out for 6 though  :o

[BomberSam]

Will I fall behind without Goldy or is Blicavs an alternative?

[js19]

NVB/Heeney---> Some downgrade since Heeney is out for 6 and NVB won't be making much more bank. Most likely NVB going.

Wait, what

Longmire said it was only precautionary and Doc Larkins reckons he'll be fit to play. However, one would think it would be a good chance to rest him - then again, he got a good rest during the second half ;)

Got a good rest in the first as well...

Some cows have to go early regardless, as most rookies will creep up in price over the season, but slow down significantly. Heeney's 7 makes him a sitting duck at the moment

[LordSneeze]

Anyone else considering swinging their R3 to fwd for Bellchambers to bring in Tarrant?
Belly is going to score about 70 every week, wont go up or drop in price. Having Tarrant instead of a floating 0 could be a massive bonus come season end.

[kilbluff1985]

Anyone else considering swinging their R3 to fwd for Bellchambers to bring in Tarrant?
Belly is going to score about 70 every week, wont go up or drop in price. Having Tarrant instead of a floating 0 could be a massive bonus come season end.

would just trade Belly to Tarrant instead

[BomberSam]

Tex Walker to Robbie Tarrant
+
Brett Goodes to Michael Hibberd

OR

Tex Walker to Robbie Tarrant
+
Brett Goodes to Jake Kelly
+
NEXT WEEK:
Salem to Goldy
+
McIntosh to Hibberd/Kelly/Simpson

Which one?

[LordSneeze]

Anyone else considering swinging their R3 to fwd for Bellchambers to bring in Tarrant?
Belly is going to score about 70 every week, wont go up or drop in price. Having Tarrant instead of a floating 0 could be a massive bonus come season end.

would just trade Belly to Tarrant instead

No ruck cover vs ruck cover.
Id prefer to have ruck cover over a floating donut. It is also a lot better for the bye rounds with my team running an extra rookie to most other teams.

[kilbluff1985]

Anyone else considering swinging their R3 to fwd for Bellchambers to bring in Tarrant?
Belly is going to score about 70 every week, wont go up or drop in price. Having Tarrant instead of a floating 0 could be a massive bonus come season end.

would just trade Belly to Tarrant instead

No ruck cover vs ruck cover.
Id prefer to have ruck cover over a floating donut. It is also a lot better for the bye rounds with my team running an extra rookie to most other teams.

look at upgrading a forward to Ryder in a few weeks

just think Belly is a waste of cash on the ruck bench

[LordSneeze]

Anyone else considering swinging their R3 to fwd for Bellchambers to bring in Tarrant?
Belly is going to score about 70 every week, wont go up or drop in price. Having Tarrant instead of a floating 0 could be a massive bonus come season end.

would just trade Belly to Tarrant instead

No ruck cover vs ruck cover.
Id prefer to have ruck cover over a floating donut. It is also a lot better for the bye rounds with my team running an extra rookie to most other teams.

look at upgrading a forward to Ryder in a few weeks

just think Belly is a waste of cash on the ruck bench

Have Ryder already. To be swung into the Fwd line later in the season.
I agree it isn't the best having cash on the bench, but then its the same as having a 0 on the bench when you can avoid it and have another cash generating player.
I do see the benefits and negatives for both though.

[HotTiges]

NVB/Heeney---> Some downgrade since Heeney is out for 6 and NVB won't be making much more bank. Most likely NVB going.

Wait, what

Longmire said it was only precautionary and Doc Larkins reckons he'll be fit to play. However, one would think it would be a good chance to rest him - then again, he got a good rest during the second half ;)

he basically didnt turn up..

[jarvis]

Bennell + Newnes OUT for Tarrant + Fyfe + 200k ITB, need thoughts on this!

Others who may go could be - Lumumba, Hurn, KK, and Gibbs...

Crazy talk, no need to trade out Bennell!

I know, sorry! Reconsidered; Lumumba + Salem > Fyfe + Tarrant!

[Silk_Touch]

anyone considering trading Gray out for Tarrant?

[Samsturmfels]

anyone considering trading Gray out for Tarrant?

Have you considered quiting Supercoach?? I think that would be a better option

[_wato]

Bennell + Newnes OUT for Tarrant + Fyfe + 200k ITB, need thoughts on this!

Others who may go could be - Lumumba, Hurn, KK, and Gibbs...

Crazy talk, no need to trade out Bennell!

I know, sorry! Reconsidered; Lumumba + Salem > Fyfe + Tarrant!

Lumumba has scored 73, 92 and 109 and has had one bad week, do not trade him yet, would wait a week on that and then reassess, however Fyfe is a must do you'll have to see where else he could come in
Do not really have a problem with Salem -> Tarrant though, go for it

[Judd Magic]

What does everyone think of these 2 trades?

Van Berlo > Tarrant via Bonts dpp

Newnes > Hibberd

$118,600 in the kitty which I could use for a direct Hunt > Simpson swap next week.

Bonts becomes my temp M6 but now only have 3 premo forwards (Gray, Swan, Martin)

Other forwards are Salem, Tarrant, Hogan (Clark, Lonie)

Do these trades look ok?