Kelly or Andrews to get Goldy

[flex350]

I am thinking about offloading Goodes so I can upgrade Minson to Goldy as I have no ruck cover.
So who do you think has the better scoring potential out of Kelly or Andrews.  Or should I look at someone else.
Kelly had 10 tackles last week, which helped his scores.  If he keeps that up he should retain his position I would hope.


Thanks

[honza]

Kelly by a mile.

Tackling machine.

[RaisyDaisy]

Very risky going with either of these options early

Any reason you didn't dump Minson earlier in the round to have more ruck options to chose from?

If you have to pick one, I think I would pick Andrews, only because Brisbane is rubbish and he might get more chances than Kelly

[honza]

Very risky going with either of these options early

Any reason you didn't dump Minson earlier in the round to have more ruck options to chose from?

If you have to pick one, I think I would pick Andrews, only because Brisbane is rubbish and he might get more chances than Kelly

When Kelly started on the rookie list the adelaide coaches were joking they might need to put him on a leash. The bloke just attacks people. And new coach Walsh loves that stuff.

Andrews is a rookie beanpole. I just can't see good scores despite maybe having JS. A bit like Charlie Dixon in his rookie year.

[RaisyDaisy]

Agree

I think Kelly is the better prospect, but Adelaide are flying and spots will be up for grabs, that was just why I leaned towards Harris

Like I said, I would try to avoid picking either this week

[flex350]

Very risky going with either of these options early

Any reason you didn't dump Minson earlier in the round to have more ruck options to chose from?

If you have to pick one, I think I would pick Andrews, only because Brisbane is rubbish and he might get more chances than Kelly

When Kelly started on the rookie list the adelaide coaches were joking they might need to put him on a leash. The bloke just attacks people. And new coach Walsh loves that stuff.

Andrews is a rookie beanpole. I just can't see good scores despite maybe having JS. A bit like Charlie Dixon in his rookie year.

I had no idea who to dump Minson for, Smith or Grundy were a couple of options but did not like either. I could go Nic Nat, but am not convinced.  Goldy should be a keeper so hopefully not a wasted trade.  Maric is my other ruck
All coaches would love someone who tackles 10 times in a match and for that reason I am considering Kelly.  I just dont know much about the lad.

[Knowall]

Kelly is there temporarily for Cheney.  Don't think he'll play when Cheney is back.

[flex350]

Am I better going for Nit Nat or trading upto Goldy and going Kelly/Andrews for Goodes

[Bully]

Am I better going for Nit Nat or trading upto Goldy and going Kelly/Andrews for Goodes

Get Goldy.

[ClarksonsArmy]

I think ANdrews based on the tall timber they need he will have better JS

I think Kelly maybe in trouble as a few ahead of him

[HotTiges]

I hope you got Goldy in..

[flex350]

I hope you got Goldy in..

Sure did, but took Andrews too.  His performance today was not great but no one from the Lions performed.