Replacement for bartel!

[steven3]

Gray vs Bont + cash

Looked in the other threads but couldnt find an answer for this so decided to make one

Just a quick vote will do
Thanks in advance

[tor01doc]

If you think The Bont will be a keeper fwd then The Bont for sure. This week he is a bargain.

[AaronKirk]

Pick the bloke come season's end who will be the best scorer. Gray to me is a no brainer.

[steven3]

Thanks for the output guys
The cash from bont would be helpful for future trades but theres a risk to picking him as to whether he can keep it up
Gray on the other hand you know will score strong all season
Tough choice

[devize]

I went with Bont and I'll probably pick up either Gray or JPK in a couple weeks with the money I saved while they drop in price

[AlexIsOnFire]

I went with Bont and I'll probably pick up either Gray or JPK in a couple weeks with the money I saved while they drop in price

My logic exactly... $155 in the kitty from picking Bont which will help when cash cows are ripening to pick up Gray.

[GCSkiwi]

I went with Bont and I'll probably pick up either Gray or JPK in a couple weeks with the money I saved while they drop in price

My logic exactly... $155 in the kitty from picking Bont which will help when cash cows are ripening to pick up Gray.

The reservation with this is yes that's fine if Bont goes 95+ for the year... but what if from here on out he goes ~80... you'll want to sideways trade him out again... I think I will take the punt on him too, just saying that's my concern, that he's not a proven choice...

[Slashers]

I had Bont temporarily in the middle so have swung him forward for Bartel and purchased Selwood.
Already have Gray.

[auscoyote]

I went with Bont and I'll probably pick up either Gray or JPK in a couple weeks with the money I saved while they drop in price

My logic exactly... $155 in the kitty from picking Bont which will help when cash cows are ripening to pick up Gray.

The reservation with this is yes that's fine if Bont goes 95+ for the year... but what if from here on out he goes ~80... you'll want to sideways trade him out again... I think I will take the punt on him too, just saying that's my concern, that he's not a proven choice...

Yep i have my doubts too with the extra attention he will receive :-\ I think i will still pick him as he should sill win a fair few CP but have also considered Motlop for 12k more. Getting more mid time now and shots on goal too.

[Ricochet]

Same situation as me mate. I went Gray, not sold on Bont just yet

[Ricochet]

Well Gray is out now, so now I have no flowering idea lol

[Tylo]

Buddy

[elephants]

Bont :P

[auscoyote]

Buddy

Will get buddy at some stage but going Bont or Motlop allows me to get JPK in 2 weeks

[crowls]

 have dead men walking everywhere.

B  Shaw, Newnes, Lumumba, Tosh, Oxley, Saad (kk, goodes)    KK/Goodes to Smith
M  Fyfe, JPK, Beams, Ward, Heeney,CEY, VDB, NVB, (Cripps, Miller, Wells*)
F  Gray Bartel*, Swan, Bont, Salem, Clark,( Hogan, Lamb*)

Option 1
wk 1   Bartel/Wells> Krak/Watson  +239 K
Wk 2  KK to Smith

This week no fwd bench cover if Bont doesnt play.   No mid DPP.   End up with donut.
Option 2
Hold till next week, pray all fwds play,  then decide Krak,  Watson over rocky or Selwood,  Wait another week for KK>Smith