NicNat

[RaisyDaisy]

92, 103, 77, 83, 83 and currently on 43 approaching 3/4 time

I know it's a luxury trade, but I am seriously considering trading him to Martin

NicNat looks like being a 85ish avg player this year, while Martin is pumping out massive scores week after week

I know luxury trades aren't ideal at the moment, but it could be a massive point gain

[whynot102]

I have him and he is severely overrated

[Big Mac]

Isn't playing that bad and is actually averaging about 8 more hit outs than last year

Just isn't translating to SC

Will definitely have to consider a trade at some point

[Grufflez]

Yeah i might have to upgrade him...massive dud

[justaverage]

Had a good last quarter, probably saved him from a 50

[RaisyDaisy]

Had a good last quarter, probably saved him from a 50

Last qtr was much better, but 70's and 80's are not good enough, especially when Martin is scoring so much more

[shaker]

His ruck work is good just not getting enough possessions

[justaverage]

As an owner of NicNat, Newnes, Griffen, Selwood, Heeney, NVB, Adcock, CEY, Sloane and Bellchambers. If I had 5 trades this round NicNat would still be in my team  :-[

[lucky]

having 85 avg compared to 110 is a huge difference. If i had no other issues in my team i would be considering trading him.
But since I have other issues, ill be looking to move him on during the byes, (if this point scoring continues).

[Dudge]

Have him in A/F, S/C and RDT, and he's been very ordinary

[GCSkiwi]

I have other trades to make at this stage but I think a nicnat upgrade will be inevitable. Still averaging 85 ish so is only falling ~25 points short on martin at the moment, there are other players that surely have bigger gaps than that (likes of newton, brayshaw, vdb, heeney, hogan, clark). Defense is also giving me the showers, at this stage I can see myself luxury trading newnes, nicnat and lumumba before I get rid of oxley and saad :P

[enzedder]

Agree that he is becoming a liability and his time in my side looks just about done. I'm fairly certain I'll be using my two trades on T Mitchell and McKenzie this week so he better perform.
He has Gold Coast and maybe the St.Kilda game to show something or he'll turn into Martin or Blicavs. Only 40k or so to Blicavs this week but other trades more of a priority.

[Jimmykidd]

If I didn't have other problems and hadn't already used 6 trades this dud would be  traded. Yes been pretty average tbh. Sinclair got 20 odd hit outs too so that killed his scoring. Just not getting the footy enough.

[RaisyDaisy]

I'm going to put up with him and just before his BYE he is out, and Martin/Jacobs comes in

Will also help me for byes as currently have Goldy and NN missing rd13, and Martin/Jacobs being 11 helps

[enzedder]

I'm going to put up with him and just before his BYE he is out, and Martin/Jacobs comes in

Will also help me for byes as currently have Goldy and NN missing rd13, and Martin/Jacobs being 11 helps

Good plan.
I'll do the same.
Glad that's sorted.  :)