Round 3 Trades

[colmullet]

ahhh i dunno which two to do!!

Goodes->Oxley
Miller -> NVB
GAJ -> Kennedy

I feel like Oxley and NVB are to good to pass up.....but having 730K sitting on the bench for a week is going to be painful to chasing a decent score to keep in touch aswell

Get your rookies right mate. you might miss out on 20-50pts this week but you can go Gazz to Kennedy next week

Although Miller can still make you some cash. Which other mid rooks do you have?

Newton, Cripps, Brayshaw, Heeny, CEY, Miller, Vandenburg

[Ricochet]

ahhh i dunno which two to do!!

Goodes->Oxley
Miller -> NVB
GAJ -> Kennedy

I feel like Oxley and NVB are to good to pass up.....but having 730K sitting on the bench for a week is going to be painful to chasing a decent score to keep in touch aswell

Get your rookies right mate. you might miss out on 20-50pts this week but you can go Gazz to Kennedy next week

Although Miller can still make you some cash. Which other mid rooks do you have?

Newton, Cripps, Brayshaw, Heeny, CEY, Miller, Vandenburg

Yeh ok. Maybe pass on VB then? Unless Brayshaw is the sub again, then maybe look at him instead.

[colmullet]

ahhh i dunno which two to do!!

Goodes->Oxley
Miller -> NVB
GAJ -> Kennedy

I feel like Oxley and NVB are to good to pass up.....but having 730K sitting on the bench for a week is going to be painful to chasing a decent score to keep in touch aswell

Get your rookies right mate. you might miss out on 20-50pts this week but you can go Gazz to Kennedy next week

Although Miller can still make you some cash. Which other mid rooks do you have?

Newton, Cripps, Brayshaw, Heeny, CEY, Miller, Vandenburg

Yeh ok. Maybe pass on VB then? Unless Brayshaw is the sub again, then maybe look at him instead.

Yeah he's really the only question mark rookie in there.....but at the same time if he gets unvested games i think he might turn out to be the best scorer of the lot haha its a tough call

[Ricochet]

ahhh i dunno which two to do!!

Goodes->Oxley
Miller -> NVB
GAJ -> Kennedy

I feel like Oxley and NVB are to good to pass up.....but having 730K sitting on the bench for a week is going to be painful to chasing a decent score to keep in touch aswell

Get your rookies right mate. you might miss out on 20-50pts this week but you can go Gazz to Kennedy next week

Although Miller can still make you some cash. Which other mid rooks do you have?

Newton, Cripps, Brayshaw, Heeny, CEY, Miller, Vandenburg

Yeh ok. Maybe pass on VB then? Unless Brayshaw is the sub again, then maybe look at him instead.

Yeah he's really the only question mark rookie in there.....but at the same time if he gets unvested games i think he might turn out to be the best scorer of the lot haha its a tough call

Yeh so do I haha.

Ok so if he does get the vest again this week then look at him to VB. Atm Brayshaw's BE is 6, but his 86 from RD1 will drop out straight away. If he scores 60 this week his BE will be 45 for next week. You'd assume that if he cops a vest then he will score less than that, giving him a much higher BE. So really, if he cops a vest, he may not make some decent money until rounds 5-6...
IF he avoids vests after this week and continues to get games

If he doesn't get a vest this week then keep him, and maybe pass on VB

Miller won't have to score as high to make cash and should get decent opportunities with GAJ out now

[colmullet]

ahhh i dunno which two to do!!

Goodes->Oxley
Miller -> NVB
GAJ -> Kennedy

I feel like Oxley and NVB are to good to pass up.....but having 730K sitting on the bench for a week is going to be painful to chasing a decent score to keep in touch aswell

Get your rookies right mate. you might miss out on 20-50pts this week but you can go Gazz to Kennedy next week

Although Miller can still make you some cash. Which other mid rooks do you have?

Newton, Cripps, Brayshaw, Heeny, CEY, Miller, Vandenburg

Yeh ok. Maybe pass on VB then? Unless Brayshaw is the sub again, then maybe look at him instead.

Yeah he's really the only question mark rookie in there.....but at the same time if he gets unvested games i think he might turn out to be the best scorer of the lot haha its a tough call

Yeh so do I haha.

Ok so if he does get the vest again this week then look at him to VB. Atm Brayshaw's BE is 6, but his 86 from RD1 will drop out straight away. If he scores 60 this week his BE will be 45 for next week. You'd assume that if he cops a vest then he will score less than that, giving him a much higher BE. So really, if he cops a vest, he may not make some decent money until rounds 5-6...
IF he avoids vests after this week and continues to get games

If he doesn't get a vest this week then keep him, and maybe pass on VB

Miller won't have to score as high to make cash and should get decent opportunities with GAJ out now

Yeah sounds like a decent plan.....now to make up my mind in DT where i have the exact same problem but with no rolling lockout hahaha

[dmac07]

Brown vs Jake Kelly for Goode's?

Security but poor scoring vs unknown security and scoring plus 20-30k? Already have saad, McIntosh, oxley

[RaisyDaisy]

Brown vs Jake Kelly for Goode's?

Security but poor scoring vs unknown security and scoring plus 20-30k? Already have saad, McIntosh, oxley

Just hang onto Goodes for now

[krk004]

Simpson, Shaw, Kelly, Newnes, Adcock, McIntosh (Saad, Oxley)
GAJ, Pendles, Watson, SWallow, CEY, VDB, Heeney, Lang (Cripps, Nelson, Miller)
Minson, NicNat (McLaren)
Gray, Bartel, Martin, Swan, Hogan, Clark (Salem, McGrath)

$5,500 left

Tossing up between;

GAJ & Miller>

1) Fyfe & Anderson?

or

2) Sloane & NVB

Due to running a 4 premo midfield, really looking to get NVB to M5, otherwise running with 4 rookie midfield.

Thoughts?

[RaisyDaisy]

Simpson, Shaw, Kelly, Newnes, Adcock, McIntosh (Saad, Oxley)
GAJ, Pendles, Watson, SWallow, CEY, VDB, Heeney, Lang (Cripps, Nelson, Miller)
Minson, NicNat (McLaren)
Gray, Bartel, Martin, Swan, Hogan, Clark (Salem, McGrath)

$5,500 left

Tossing up between;

GAJ & Miller>

1) Fyfe & Anderson?

or

2) Sloane & NVB

Due to running a 4 premo midfield, really looking to get NVB to M5, otherwise running with 4 rookie midfield.

Thoughts?

Sloane and NVB 100%. You need NVB with that midfield

[krk004]

Simpson, Shaw, Kelly, Newnes, Adcock, McIntosh (Saad, Oxley)
GAJ, Pendles, Watson, SWallow, CEY, VDB, Heeney, Lang (Cripps, Nelson, Miller)
Minson, NicNat (McLaren)
Gray, Bartel, Martin, Swan, Hogan, Clark (Salem, McGrath)

$5,500 left

Tossing up between;

GAJ & Miller>

1) Fyfe & Anderson?

or

2) Sloane & NVB

Due to running a 4 premo midfield, really looking to get NVB to M5, otherwise running with 4 rookie midfield.

Thoughts?

Sloane and NVB 100%. You need NVB with that midfield

Cheers,

[dickitch]

So i'm keen on going Cripps to NVB a lot like others but i can't by $1k - sooo based on Beams unlikely BE and loss of cash would Beams to Rich be a bad idea?  Rich will raise in value and I can still re-evaluate in a couple of weeks and swap back if needed.

Any other obvious options - all that said I can field a full side with no changes this week, but don't really want to miss the cash from NVB (and even Rich)?

Edit: also leaves me with a very nice $271k to play with

[Ricochet]

No, Beams is a keeper and top 10 mid. If he only scores 100 this week he will only drop 30k. You'd like to think he'd bounce back and score more than that

[dickitch]

but remember without downgrading a keeper, even if temporarily i miss out on NVB (and Rich) - are the 2 trades and risk worth it, or suck it up and field what I have?

[Bully]

I don't see it as a bad idea, Beams is copping the number 1 tag at Brisbane and appears to be struggling. He's about to haemorrhage significant cash and the gap bewteen the two will close very quickly.

[Ricochet]

I don't see it as a bad idea, Beams is copping the number 1 tag at Brisbane and appears to be struggling. He's about to haemorrhage significant cash and the gap bewteen the two will close very quickly.

He's not going to lose that much cash unless he posts another <90 score. He scored 108 in RD1. If he posts another two 110ish scores over the next 2 weeks he'll only lose 30-50k-ish