Round 3 Trades

[BomberSam]

Ablett to Sloane and Cripps to Shiel...

Thoughts?

Fantastic

Leaves me with only 6k in the bank. Is it still alright?

[Huttabito]

Gazza -> Bonts
Cocky -> NVB
$489,000 left in bank!

[jfitty]

With the Ablett development he now obviously has to go.

Want to take this opportunity to trade Bellchambers > Goldstein, which leaves me to decide between:

Ablett > Rich + 120k
Ablett > Bont (who could be a forward keeper)

Thoughts?

[Sabretooth Tigers]

 :'(

Well there's no doubt now, it is bye, bye Gazza.  But I am stuffed when it comes to who to bring in.  Can be anybody except for Martin, Gray, Bennell or Bont who I already have up forward. Needs to be someone I can throw the big "C" on, especially this week as Pendles is doubtful. Really need 3 trades. I want NVB and a Gazza replacement in the middle and I'd like to bring Docherty in defence. I'm really stumped on this one and I'd need to trade Gazza in order to have the $'s to get Docherty. Could go Gazza for NVB and then Hendersen or Nathan Brown for Docherty and wait around or two to get the extra mid prem. The trouble with that is that I'm in the top 1000 in the overall and would drop dramatically if I don't get the prem mid in now.
Fyfe,  Pendles,  Prestia,   and Griffen plus rookies in the middle but who to add.   PLEASE  help by making suggestions as I really am stuffed on this one. Cheers and thanks in anticipation, from pete the oldfart.( Where I come from an oldfart is one who is over 50, has grey or little hair, has usually spent time in one of the services, has old fashioned values and a bloody outrageous sense of humour, and grand illusions of winning Supercoach )  Cheers.    :)

[enzedder]

Ablett to Sloane and Cripps to Shiel...

Thoughts?

Fantastic

Leaves me with only 6k in the bank. Is it still alright?

That's fine... Sometimes I've done trades that left me with $100 in the bank... If you get quality in that's great. Sloane for Ablett is a great trade as Sloane is a true super premium who is likely to be in all top sides soon enough. Cripps to Shiel is massive. 300k upgrade for someone you think is an underpriced keeper. If Cripps is named/ you have Cockatoo/ don't have Bontempelli/ don't have van Berlo then you have other options but as far as the trades stand there is nothing wrong with them. Having 6k in the bank only impacts on your next trades... Hard to comment further without knowing your team.
I'm in a similar position this week and can afford a premium for Cripps which will leave me with virtually nothing as well.
Yet I'm considering getting Van Berlo as he will make in excess of 200k and I can still spend my banked money next week.

[enzedder]

:'(

Well there's no doubt now, it is bye, bye Gazza.  But I am stuffed when it comes to who to bring in.  Can be anybody except for Martin, Gray, Bennell or Bont who I already have up forward. Needs to be someone I can throw the big "C" on, especially this week as Pendles is doubtful. Really need 3 trades. I want NVB and a Gazza replacement in the middle and I'd like to bring Docherty in defence. I'm really stumped on this one and I'd need to trade Gazza in order to have the $'s to get Docherty. Could go Gazza for NVB and then Hendersen or Nathan Brown for Docherty and wait around or two to get the extra mid prem. The trouble with that is that I'm in the top 1000 in the overall and would drop dramatically if I don't get the prem mid in now.
Fyfe,  Pendles,  Prestia,   and Griffen plus rookies in the middle but who to add.   PLEASE  help by making suggestions as I really am stuffed on this one. Cheers and thanks in anticipation, from pete the oldfart.( Where I come from an oldfart is one who is over 50, has grey or little hair, has usually spent time in one of the services, has old fashioned values and a bloody outrageous sense of humour, and grand illusions of winning Supercoach )  Cheers.    :)

JPK or Sloane for GAJ
I'd be getting NVB this week too.
Wait on defenders another week. Midfielders is where the points and dollars are when trying to get near the top or stay there.

[Sabretooth Tigers]

:'(

Well there's no doubt now, it is bye, bye Gazza.  But I am stuffed when it comes to who to bring in.  Can be anybody except for Martin, Gray, Bennell or Bont who I already have up forward. Needs to be someone I can throw the big "C" on, especially this week as Pendles is doubtful. Really need 3 trades. I want NVB and a Gazza replacement in the middle and I'd like to bring Docherty in defence. I'm really stumped on this one and I'd need to trade Gazza in order to have the $'s to get Docherty. Could go Gazza for NVB and then Hendersen or Nathan Brown for Docherty and wait around or two to get the extra mid prem. The trouble with that is that I'm in the top 1000 in the overall and would drop dramatically if I don't get the prem mid in now.
Fyfe,  Pendles,  Prestia,   and Griffen plus rookies in the middle but who to add.   PLEASE  help by making suggestions as I really am stuffed on this one. Cheers and thanks in anticipation, from pete the oldfart.( Where I come from an oldfart is one who is over 50, has grey or little hair, has usually spent time in one of the services, has old fashioned values and a bloody outrageous sense of humour, and grand illusions of winning Supercoach )  Cheers.    :)

JPK or Sloane for GAJ
I'd be getting NVB this week too.
Wait on defenders another week. Midfielders is where the points and dollars are when trying to get near the top or stay there.

Thanks bigtime enzedder, I was beginning to wander off the path.  Was thinking of the same trade as you earlier. Would Sloane have the higher ceiling ?  Cheers.     :) 8) ;)

[enzedder]

Gazza -> Bonts
Cocky -> NVB
$489,000 left in bank!

:)
You'd be wanting to spend that money the next week then. Too much to sit on.
Both players are popular choices this week.

[Blues Blues Blues]

Def: Shaw, Lamumba, Newnes, Ibbotson, Goodes, Mcintosh (Saad, Oxley)
Mid: GAJ, Fyfe, Beams, JPK, Swan, Cripps, CEY, Vandenberg (Cockatoo, Heeney, Miller)
Ruc: Goldy, NicNat (Mclaren)
Fwd: Gray, Dusty, Bennell, Salem, Clark, Hogan (Lonie, Lamb)

Cash: $200k

Thinking:
GAJ -> Bont
Miller -> NVB or Rich (can't decide)

Leaves $419k for next week to probably upgrade Goodes to Smith.

Thoughts??

[Jesty]

Z Clark>Bonts.
Cocky>CEY

[enzedder]

:'(

Well there's no doubt now, it is bye, bye Gazza.  But I am stuffed when it comes to who to bring in.  Can be anybody except for Martin, Gray, Bennell or Bont who I already have up forward. Needs to be someone I can throw the big "C" on, especially this week as Pendles is doubtful. Really need 3 trades. I want NVB and a Gazza replacement in the middle and I'd like to bring Docherty in defence. I'm really stumped on this one and I'd need to trade Gazza in order to have the $'s to get Docherty. Could go Gazza for NVB and then Hendersen or Nathan Brown for Docherty and wait around or two to get the extra mid prem. The trouble with that is that I'm in the top 1000 in the overall and would drop dramatically if I don't get the prem mid in now.
Fyfe,  Pendles,  Prestia,   and Griffen plus rookies in the middle but who to add.   PLEASE  help by making suggestions as I really am stuffed on this one. Cheers and thanks in anticipation, from pete the oldfart.( Where I come from an oldfart is one who is over 50, has grey or little hair, has usually spent time in one of the services, has old fashioned values and a bloody outrageous sense of humour, and grand illusions of winning Supercoach )  Cheers.    :)

JPK or Sloane for GAJ
I'd be getting NVB this week too.
Wait on defenders another week. Midfielders is where the points and dollars are when trying to get near the top or stay there.

Thanks bigtime enzedder, I was beginning to wander off the path.  Was thinking of the same trade as you earlier. Would Sloane have the higher ceiling ?  Cheers.     :) 8) ;)

No crystal ball for that one...both have gone over 170, would've said JPK more consistent at going 130+ but also can have the odd low scores and Sloane has started this year slightly better...splitting hairs...get both!

[Huttabito]

Def: Shaw, Lamumba, Newnes, Ibbotson, Goodes, Mcintosh (Saad, Oxley)
Mid: GAJ, Fyfe, Beams, JPK, Swan, Cripps, CEY, Vandenberg (Cockatoo, Heeney, Miller)
Ruc: Goldy, NicNat (Mclaren)
Fwd: Gray, Dusty, Bennell, Salem, Clark, Hogan (Lonie, Lamb)

Cash: $200k

Thinking:
GAJ -> Bont
Miller -> NVB or Rich (can't decide)

Leaves $419k for next week to probably upgrade Goodes to Smith.

Thoughts??

I've done this, except Cocky to NVB instead of Miller.
I guess with Gazza now out is slightly improves Millers JS.. just.. and his BE is 4 should at least make a bit of coin. Cocky is perfect sub-bait with a BE of 53 will most likely only lose money for now.

[enzedder]

Def: Shaw, Lamumba, Newnes, Ibbotson, Goodes, Mcintosh (Saad, Oxley)
Mid: GAJ, Fyfe, Beams, JPK, Swan, Cripps, CEY, Vandenberg (Cockatoo, Heeney, Miller)
Ruc: Goldy, NicNat (Mclaren)
Fwd: Gray, Dusty, Bennell, Salem, Clark, Hogan (Lonie, Lamb)

Cash: $200k

Thinking:
GAJ -> Bont
Miller -> NVB or Rich (can't decide)

Leaves $419k for next week to probably upgrade Goodes to Smith.

Thoughts??

NVB over Rich for mine.
Cheaper and think he'll make more coin.
Also one team is flying and one is struggling.
Brisbane are missing some big names and Rich may score well and make good money but NVB looks the better choice by some margin IMO.

[BigMac_93]

I have 3 trades that I need to do.

GAJ > Sloane or JPK
N Brown > McIntosh
Cripps > NVB.

Do you guys think I should hold GAJ for one more week and do the other 2 trades. Or just trade GAJ this week and hold onto Cripps?

[enzedder]

With the Ablett development he now obviously has to go.

Want to take this opportunity to trade Bellchambers > Goldstein, which leaves me to decide between:

Ablett > Rich + 120k
Ablett > Bont (who could be a forward keeper)

Thoughts?

I have Bontempelli already for Deledio last week, currently in mids and believe he will be a fwd keeper so that's the way I'd go.