Backline Trades - KK, Goodes, Lumumba

[Southstorm]

Currently I have Shaw, Newnes, Lumumba, Ibbo, McIntosh Goodes (Oxley,Saad).
Happy to persist with Newnes and I believe Harry will only get better.

Want to moves Goodes OUT but not sure for who....suggestions???

I'm in a very similar position, I'm considering going up to Taylor Hunt or trading Goodes down to some rookie who might play later in the year and fielding two of Oxley, Saad and McIntosh. Geary is another option if you can stretch.

[Asparagus]

Currently I have Shaw, Newnes, Lumumba, Ibbo, McIntosh Goodes (Oxley,Saad).
Happy to persist with Newnes and I believe Harry will only get better.

Want to moves Goodes OUT but not sure for who....suggestions???

I'm in a very similar position, I'm considering going up to Taylor Hunt or trading Goodes down to some rookie who might play later in the year and fielding two of Oxley, Saad and McIntosh. Geary is another option if you can stretch.

Can't afford Geary  so it will have to be a rookie. I am happy to field Oxley after seeing him play live tonight.
Gets a lot of it, butchers it but still gets it a lot.

Would stay away from T Hunt, he has 4 big games a year and that's it. A Teaser.

[TexR74]

Hibberd to McDonald
Cripps to Adams/Rich/Blicavs/Bell

OR

Hibberd to Smith
Goodes to Hunt/MacMillan

Should I forcus on the back or take care of a mid problem?

[muggle25]

I'd hold Cripps - only dropped due to soreness.  In a struggling side the Blues are going to want to get games into this guy - he has great upside for them.  I am certainly holding Cripps.

[Money Shot]

Simpson, Shaw, Newnes, Lumumba, Goodes, McIntosh (Oxley, Saad)

That is my current defence line up and I want to trade Goodes to someone cheaper to allow me to go Miller>NVB in the mids ... Is there anyone that I haven't got that I should consider (Not Brown) for me to get some cash?

[RaisyDaisy]

Simpson, Shaw, Newnes, Lumumba, Goodes, McIntosh (Oxley, Saad)

That is my current defence line up and I want to trade Goodes to someone cheaper to allow me to go Miller>NVB in the mids ... Is there anyone that I haven't got that I should consider (Not Brown) for me to get some cash?

Nope

Brown the only option, unless you take a risk on Goddard which you can use to loophole in the meantime and hope he eventually gets games

[Money Shot]

Simpson, Shaw, Newnes, Lumumba, Goodes, McIntosh (Oxley, Saad)

That is my current defence line up and I want to trade Goodes to someone cheaper to allow me to go Miller>NVB in the mids ... Is there anyone that I haven't got that I should consider (Not Brown) for me to get some cash?

Nope

Brown the only option, unless you take a risk on Goddard which you can use to loophole in the meantime and hope he eventually gets games

Ah well, I think I would still prefer Goodes than Brown (that's how much I hate Brown in sc)

[Torpedo10]

Simpson, Shaw, Newnes, Lumumba, Goodes, McIntosh (Oxley, Saad)

That is my current defence line up and I want to trade Goodes to someone cheaper to allow me to go Miller>NVB in the mids ... Is there anyone that I haven't got that I should consider (Not Brown) for me to get some cash?

Nope

Brown the only option, unless you take a risk on Goddard which you can use to loophole in the meantime and hope he eventually gets games

Scharenberg is another Option.

[James_Pies]

What to do with KK after that score? Hold?

[Bully]

What to do with KK after that score? Hold?

I would consider an upgrade, particularly if you have the funds to pick up Smith (although likely to miss a week).

[James_Pies]

What to do with KK after that score? Hold?

I would consider an upgrade, particularly if you have the funds to pick up Smith (although likely to miss a week).

Would it be stupid to go Gaz to Shiel wait and if smith misses a week wait one week and trade KK to Smith?

[Bully]

What to do with KK after that score? Hold?

I would consider an upgrade, particularly if you have the funds to pick up Smith (although likely to miss a week).

Would it be stupid to go Gaz to Shiel wait and if smith misses a week wait one week and trade KK to Smith?

No, I think Shiel is about to have a breakout season, 2 BOG's and he's hitting the scoreboard as well. I like these trades.

[dmac07]

Currently I have Shaw, Newnes, Lumumba, Ibbo, McIntosh Goodes (Oxley,Saad).
Happy to persist with Newnes and I believe Harry will only get better.

Want to moves Goodes OUT but not sure for who....suggestions???

I'm in a very similar position, I'm considering going up to Taylor Hunt or trading Goodes down to some rookie who might play later in the year and fielding two of Oxley, Saad and McIntosh. Geary is another option if you can stretch.

Exact same backline except Pearce instead of Goodes. Happy to field 2 of Mcintosh, saad, oxley. But who to go for goodes to put on bench? Want to use the cash to go Miller to NVB

[MC]

Copping a mid price floggin in my backs.     
Shaw, Lumumba, Newnes, KK (POD), Goodes, Saad, (mcintosh, oxley)

Exactly the same backs as me! Haha
I'm still dirty I dropped docherty for kk,  want to find a way to get Goodes up to docherty at this stage. Kk, Newnes and Lumumba are scoring well enough to keep for now

[frenzy]

Don't get sucked into McDonald

He's more consistant than Savage or Geary, so don't understand your comment. ???