Round 2 West Coast v Carlton - Friday 10th Domain Stadium

Started by LF, April 07, 2015, 10:09:29 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Nige


Bill Manspeaker

consistency ump. hows that not high on Menzel when the free was paid to the head down bulldozing Eagle before

LF


Mailman the 2nd

Quote from: Bill Manspeaker on April 10, 2015, 08:54:44 PM
consistency ump. hows that not high on Menzel when the free was paid to the head down bulldozing Eagle before

Yeah the inconsistent calls are shafting Carlton here tbh

Mailman the 2nd


Nige

Holy shower the umps have been ordinary both ways tonight.

Nige


quinny88

This game could be over if West Coast could kick straight

Mat0369

Did you guys notice Jamo's jumper outstretched there?

AaronKirk

Quote from: Mat0369 on April 10, 2015, 09:09:15 PM
Did you guys notice Jamo's jumper outstretched there?

Yeah, but the arm over JJK's shoulder more noticeable

Nige


Mat0369

Quote from: AaronKirk on April 10, 2015, 09:10:13 PM
Yeah, but the arm over JJK's shoulder more noticeable

And it was a free for holding not over the shoulder, just let it play

Mailman the 2nd

tbh Clem Smith shouldn't really be playing AFL this year

LF

1/2

13   Luke Shuey   71
9   Nic Naitanui   67
17   Josh Kennedy   65
11   Matt Priddis   54
29   Scott Lycett   53
24   Matt Rosa   52
3   Andrew Gaff   50
5   Brad Sheppard   47
12   Sharrod Wellingham   41
7   Chris Masten   40
31   Will Schofield   40
4   Dom Sheed   30
6   Elliot Yeo   30
20   Jeremy McGovern   30
2   Mark LeCras   30
15   Jamie Cripps   29
30   Jackson Nelson   27
32   Simon Tunbridge   26
25   Shannon Hurn   19
44   Jamie Bennell   18
35   Patrick McGinnity   13
14   Liam Duggan   0

42   Zach Tuohy   74
5   Chris Judd   68
4   Bryce Gibbs   64
13   Chris Yarran   64
15   Sam Docherty   53
3   Marc Murphy   50
33   Andrejs Everitt   46
6   Kade Simpson   44
35   Ed Curnow   43
36   Cameron Wood   40
44   Andrew Carrazzo   37
28   Tom Bell   37
23   Lachie Henderson   32
17   Sam Rowe   29
41   Levi Casboult   25
40   Michael Jamison   25
46   David Ellard   21
22   Jason Tutt   19
14   Liam Jones   17
2   Troy Menzel   14
25   Clem Smith   3
43   Simon White   1

Nige

Quote from: Mailman the 2nd on April 10, 2015, 09:13:26 PM
tbh Clem Smith shouldn't really be playing AFL this year
He was named the sub for a good reason.

Unfortunately for Carlton, they've had to bring him on in the first quarter two games in a row.

Needs time in the VFL though, plenty of it.