Oxley or Brown???

[Samsturmfels]

quick poll, should i put brown or oxley in my team, on the bench

[HotTiges]

Neither fill me with confidence.. Brown is safe as houses with JS but is injury prone and scores like a plodder. Oxley I know nothing about but is named in a FWD pocket.. flip a coin

[AaronKirk]

Brown would have the better JS.

[Big Mac]

Brown - Guaranteed points each week

[Jroo]

Neither, I'm going for Goddard ;)
But if I had to pick, Ox.

[Huttabito]

I know Pendles has Oxley in his team  8)

[HotTiges]

the temptation of removing for example.. Ibbotson, Pearce Macmillan etc to Saad and have Ox and Brown emerg is tempting.. especially with Macintosh's score

[Desired7]

How do you guys rate his Job Security, Seedsman not in side could this have an effect on his JS, and is he a sub candidate early on

[Desired7]

Im tempted to hold Birchall and back him to play next season, move Saad into the midfield, and grab oxley down back for d8 position. would that work guys

[Mark]

yea I did the same kinda, moved Saad to mids in place of CEY, then put Oxley as D8

[Fid]

Courtesy of Champion Data...

Age 22

Oxley's second season at Collingwood was derailed by an ankle injury that restricted him to just 3 VFL games.  In 2013 he was ranked No. 1 at Collingwood (VFL Side) in kicks, effective kicks and uncontested possessions, 2nd in disposals and 5th in tackles.

[Desired7]

yea I did the same kinda, moved Saad to mids in place of CEY, then put Oxley as D8

would you recomend bringing in goddard for the loophole in defence to loop hole mcintosh, oxley for the first few weeks untill i can make a decision on a premo r4-5

[Mark]

yea I did the same kinda, moved Saad to mids in place of CEY, then put Oxley as D8

would you recomend bringing in goddard for the loophole in defence to loop hole mcintosh, oxley for the first few weeks untill i can make a decision on a premo r4-5

The thing with Goddard is not sure when he will get games.. the loophole you could still use between Saad in the mids and im sure you have Newnes in Def..

If you went Goddard do you have another F/D you could swap with him if needed ?

[Desired7]

yea I did the same kinda, moved Saad to mids in place of CEY, then put Oxley as D8

would you recomend bringing in goddard for the loophole in defence to loop hole mcintosh, oxley for the first few weeks untill i can make a decision on a premo r4-5

The thing with Goddard is not sure when he will get games.. the loophole you could still use between Saad in the mids and im sure you have Newnes in Def..

If you went Goddard do you have another F/D you could swap with him if needed ?

dnt have one but could higgins be that man

[Jroo]

Looked good in the NAB Cup, but JS is shaky, one bad game and he's out.