Ask Jay: Round 4

[Hazza09]

Not sure if I should go Lewis or Sloane for Gaz...is Lewis an elite mid?

[Jay]

Cripps/Brayshaw > Rich, Miller > NVB, Bellchambers > Bont or Goodes > Higgins
which one would you choose?

Miller --> NVB

[Jay]

Not sure if I should go Lewis or Sloane for Gaz...is Lewis an elite mid?

He is elite, but not as elite as Sloane. ;)

[Donnie Brasco]

Hey mate,

Forgot to get Oxley in for Goodes...

Should I now just look at:

Ablett > JPK/ Sloane

Miller/ Newton/ Cripps > NVB

Who goes? Who stays?

Thanks in advance, much appreciated.

[Jay]

Hey mate,

Forgot to get Oxley in for Goodes...

Should I now just look at:

Ablett > JPK/ Sloane

Miller/ Newton/ Cripps > NVB

Who goes? Who stays?

Thanks in advance, much appreciated.

Yeah man, I've grabbed JPK but it's really a 50/50 between those two.

And then I'd trade Miller for NVB. He's had a couple of cracks at it and shown nothing.

[Donnie Brasco]

Thanks JM!

It's a real toss of the coin, isn't it?!

[TexR74]

Thinking of using two trades:
One i'm definitely using is Goodes to Hunt
The other one i cant decide between:
Griffen to Neale/Hanneberry
Hibberd to Smith/Simpson
Which of the two, and in that trade which player to go to?

[Woppa15]

Now that I've got my corrective trades out of the way. Thinking of implementing the Bruyn Manouvere and going Goodes > Bontempelli via Saad DPP and ride his price and trade out later on for a fallen Gray/JPK/Pendles.
Also will trade Bartel > Buddy due to injury.

Too risky too early on? What's chances of the Boofont scoring a few more early season tonnes?

[Jay]

Thinking of using two trades:
One i'm definitely using is Goodes to Hunt
The other one i cant decide between:
Griffen to Neale/Hanneberry
Hibberd to Smith/Simpson
Which of the two, and in that trade which player to go to?

I don't like Goodes to Hunt or either of the other options to be honest mate. I think Goodes doesn't have enough value to try and trade him to another keeper, I'd look at just holding him until a rookie comes along. Hunt has started well, but he doesn't seem like a keeper.

Griffen and Hibberd have started slow but its too early to trade them yet in my opinion. Give them time. I'd just hold, you don't have to use 2 trades every week.

[Jay]

Now that I've got my corrective trades out of the way. Thinking of implementing the Bruyn Manouvere and going Goodes > Bontempelli via Saad DPP and ride his price and trade out later on for a fallen Gray/JPK/Pendles.
Also will trade Bartel > Buddy due to injury.

Too risky too early on? What's chances of the Boofont scoring a few more early season tonnes?

Go for it mate, I'm actually looking at something similar.

Bonts is going to sky rocket in price, get on while you can. Bartel to Buddy is fine too. Wait for teams, but should be able to lock that double trade in no worries :)

[tkringle]

Last week I went GAJ to NBV for the cash grab, now need to bring in an ultra premium mid to replace him with..

The only issue is who out of Sheed, Cripps, Vandenberg and Miller do i trade out? All looked pretty good on the weekend and should continue to get 70-80 points a week as well as rise in price.

[greco272]

Last week I went GAJ to NBV for the cash grab, now need to bring in an ultra premium mid to replace him with..

The only issue is who out of Sheed, Cripps, Vandenberg and Miller do i trade out? All looked pretty good on the weekend and should continue to get 70-80 points a week as well as rise in price.

Can you use this money in the FWDS or BACKS??

[Jay]

Last week I went GAJ to NBV for the cash grab, now need to bring in an ultra premium mid to replace him with..

The only issue is who out of Sheed, Cripps, Vandenberg and Miller do i trade out? All looked pretty good on the weekend and should continue to get 70-80 points a week as well as rise in price.

I think its too early to trade any of them. I'd try and use the cash on grabbing another back, ruck or fwd premium and then coming back to your mids later.

[HotTiges]

Jayman brother..

Whats your thoughts on Uselesschambers at F4.i have 142k in the kitty so can grab Bonts if recommended..

[Blues Blues Blues]

Jayman,

I have $284k. I have Goodes. Together I have $512,700.

I want Smith, but he is $524,900.

I can afford any defender except Smith and Hodge.

Is Birchall a good choice? Only played 2 games, and looked good on weekend.

Thoughts?