Ask Jay: Round 4

[Jay]

Any way to better a 5 premo lineup of

Gaz Pendles Fyfe Selwood Jpk

any changes ud make

No mate. That's as good as it gets.

[DoctorRush]

Thanks for your last response Jay.

How bout :-

(1) Mumford + Anderson + Salem
(2) Luey + Brayshaw + Belly + 70k to spread around

Cheers

[Bully]

Any way to better a 5 premo lineup of

Gaz Pendles Fyfe Selwood Jpk

any changes ud make

4 round 12 bye players is the kicker, just make sure you have beefed up other lines.

[Jay]

Thanks for your last response Jay.

How bout :-

(1) Mumford + Anderson + Salem
(2) Luey + Brayshaw + Belly + 70k to spread around

Cheers

Option 1. Mumford is one of the best scoring ruckman in the comp and is worth the hefty price tag. Anderson and Salem have the most money making ability out of all the cheap guys you have listed. I just can't see Brayshaw and Belly averaging high enough to justify their price tags.

[Mahogany]

Hibbered >Goodes     To finance Newton >Steven    ( Goodes at D5 and Steven at M5 ).  Good move?

[Bully]

Hibbered >Goodes     To finance Newton >Steven    ( Goodes at D5 and Steven at M5 ).  Good move?

Very good move.

[Jay]

Hibbered >Goodes     To finance Newton >Steven    ( Goodes at D5 and Steven at M5 ).  Good move?

Very good move.

Yep excellent move. Goodes is solid enough to be a D5 and Steven is one of the best value piccks this year imo.

[Hawker_08]

G'day Jayman, Wonderful thread u have going. Doing alot for the FF community. Would u mind if u had a look at my team.

Def: Shaw, Taylor, Newnes, Lumumba, Goodes, Saad, (Hamling, McIntosh)

Mid: Ablett, Pendles, Fyfe, Parker, Griffen, Newton, Cripps, CEY, (Heeney, Miller, Steele)

Ruck: Goldy, Maric (Read)

Fwd: Gray, Martin, Swan, Salem, Clark, Hogan, (Lamb, Lambert)

Also Brayshaw vs Newton, Danger vs Parker, Goldy vs Niatanui and Pendles vs Jelwood

Cheers in advance

[Free Kick]

Can't decide..

BEAMS v's JPK

Thoughts ??

[JimmyMcNulty]

Cotchin vs Wines vs Griffin?

[Jay]

G'day Jayman, Wonderful thread u have going. Doing alot for the FF community. Would u mind if u had a look at my team.

Def: Shaw, Taylor, Newnes, Lumumba, Goodes, Saad, (Hamling, McIntosh)

Mid: Ablett, Pendles, Fyfe, Parker, Griffen, Newton, Cripps, CEY, (Heeney, Miller, Steele)

Ruck: Goldy, Maric (Read)

Fwd: Gray, Martin, Swan, Salem, Clark, Hogan, (Lamb, Lambert)

Also Brayshaw vs Newton, Danger vs Parker, Goldy vs Niatanui and Pendles vs Jelwood

Cheers in advance

No problems at all mate.

DEF: I like how you've gone a bit unique with the Taylor pick. Nice! No changes needed, just monitor the rookies who are named.

MID: Another solid line, with Griff and Parker the unique picks. If you need some cash elsewhere, I'd suggest changing Griff to Jack Steven but if you're happy with the structure at the moment, its still very solid.

RUC: Would advise against Maric, he's had trouble getting on the park in the past and you don't have any cover for him. Try and find someone more durable. Jacobs is the obvious one but will require a little tinkering to gain enough cash.

FWD: Yeah really good, taking advantage of all the fwd rookies that are set to be named. Premium choices are faultless.

Brayshaw over Newton - think he has the higher scoring potential
Danger over Parker - Parker broke out last year and is at the peak of his price, whereas Danger will almost certainly improve on last year. Both are solid selections though.
Goldy over Nic Nat - if you have the extra cash, Goldy is definitely worth it due to his consistency and durability.
Pendles over Jelwood - Pendles cracks the ton more than anyone. He is as solid as it gets.

[Hawker_08]

G'day Jayman, Wonderful thread u have going. Doing alot for the FF community. Would u mind if u had a look at my team.

Def: Shaw, Taylor, Newnes, Lumumba, Goodes, Saad, (Hamling, McIntosh)

Mid: Ablett, Pendles, Fyfe, Parker, Griffen, Newton, Cripps, CEY, (Heeney, Miller, Steele)

Ruck: Goldy, Maric (Read)

Fwd: Gray, Martin, Swan, Salem, Clark, Hogan, (Lamb, Lambert)

Also Brayshaw vs Newton, Danger vs Parker, Goldy vs Niatanui and Pendles vs Jelwood

Cheers in advance

No problems at all mate.

DEF: I like how you've gone a bit unique with the Taylor pick. Nice! No changes needed, just monitor the rookies who are named.

MID: Another solid line, with Griff and Parker the unique picks. If you need some cash elsewhere, I'd suggest changing Griff to Jack Steven but if you're happy with the structure at the moment, its still very solid.

RUC: Would advise against Maric, he's had trouble getting on the park in the past and you don't have any cover for him. Try and find someone more durable. Jacobs is the obvious one but will require a little tinkering to gain enough cash.

FWD: Yeah really good, taking advantage of all the fwd rookies that are set to be named. Premium choices are faultless.

Brayshaw over Newton - think he has the higher scoring potential
Danger over Parker - Parker broke out last year and is at the peak of his price, whereas Danger will almost certainly improve on last year. Both are solid selections though.
Goldy over Nic Nat - if you have the extra cash, Goldy is definitely worth it due to his consistency and durability.
Pendles over Jelwood - Pendles cracks the ton more than anyone. He is as solid as it gets.

Cheers for the feedbak. What are your thoughts on Pendles > Lewis, Parker > Danger, Brayshaw > VDB, Lamb > TBC now that bmbers players have been cleared or would u stick with the original. Thanks

[Slammer]

Hey Jay,

Is it worth now to start Ablett and Rocky?
Then if either one of them looks like they will struggle to maintain their form again you could trade before their price drop.

Also I still have 3 rookies in fwd line including Hogan..Is Hogan worth it?

Cheers

[AFLWizard]

Jpk vs beams

jpk/beams, cockatoo, bartel

vs

Griff sheed gray

[Keeper27]

Which bombers are truly in consideration??
Jobe/Hibberd & Belly??