Ask Jay: Round 4

[vossy12]

ablett - sloane (done)

goodes to oxley
or
miller - nvb

[Hawker_08]

Am i better off going Lambert > McGrath (and miss out on the cash cows that are NVB and rich) or should i go Goodes > Rich/Van Berlo (but miss out on rookies and have no fwd cover). Srsly need help.

[Jay]

Jay, doing two rookie correctional trade this week.

Miller > NVB
Lamb > ?? I think my only options are Lonie or McGrath
Current fwd line is, Gray, Martin, Goddard, Clark, Salem, Hogan,(Saad, Lamb)
Who is best out of Lonie or McGrath? Or anyone else?

McGrath mate. Think he has much better JS, and more of a chance to avoid the vest.

[Jay]

Would love to know your opinion Jay.

Currently gone:
Ablett to Kennedy.

Can't decide between:
Goodes to Oxley
Or
Beams to Rich

I know we shouldn't trade out premiums but beams looked horrible and uninterested in my opinion last week.  It would also gain me more money and rich will be an easy upgrade in a few weeks. 
Originally I saw Beams as a top 10 mid,  but now I am unsure. Would love to hear your opinion, keeping in mind I am going for overall.  Can post the rest of my team if necessary =)

Thanks in advance.

Goodes to Oxley for sure. Be patient with Beams, he'll come good.

[Jay]

Hey mate,

Just need some help with my trades if you wouldnt mind

Definately going Cocky > NVB this week but the other trade im not too sure on

GAJ > Sloane
Will give me 111,900 for the Brown > Oxley trade next week
Projected Brown > Oxley will give me -22,353 leaving me with 89,547 for future trades

or

Brown > Oxley
Will give me 17,200 and a GAJ > Sloane trade next week
Projected GAJ > Sloane will give me 95,158 and overall 112,358 for future trades

Projections done on current average*

Which do you think is the other trade i should make this week? Go for points with gaj to sloane or for money with brown to oxley

Thanks in advance

Hmm tough one. But in your situation, I'd grab the cash cows - they're more important at this stage than the GAJ trade. Oxley is going to rise too much for it to be worth grabbing him next week.

[Jay]

What do you think.
Im going for league wins this year.

I have bought OXley in for Goodes
Have Ablett to trade. Missing Rich and NVB. Would you think it is worth downgrading to either of these and using the cash to upgrade in the coming weeks as players hit the bubble.

Nah mate, I don't think either Rich or NVB are absolute musts. You're better off grabbing another premium for Ablett and waiting for other downgrade targets.

[Jay]

ablett - sloane (done)

goodes to oxley
or
miller - nvb

Oxley is the rookie you want. If it means getting rid of Goodes, then so be it. I'd do that.

[Jay]

Am i better off going Lambert > McGrath (and miss out on the cash cows that are NVB and rich) or should i go Goodes > Rich/Van Berlo (but miss out on rookies and have no fwd cover). Srsly need help.

If you have no fwd cover, then grab McGrath.

[TexR74]

Rich vs NVB? Probably get this a lot

[Jay]

Rich vs NVB? Probably get this a lot

NVB. Cheaper, and in my opinion will make more cash.

Not sold on Rich.

[hawkboy80]

Gaz to Robbie Grey or Sloane ?

[Jay]

Gaz to Robbie Grey or Sloane ?

Sloane. He's a flowering superstar ;D

[hawkboy80]

Gaz to Robbie Grey or Sloane ?

Sloane. He's a flowering superstar ;D

:D

[Blairholt]

Cripps/Brayshaw > Rich, Miller > NVB, Bellchambers > Bont or Goodes > Higgins
which one would you choose?

[Samsturmfels]

Cripps/Brayshaw > Rich, Miller > NVB, Bellchambers > Bont or Goodes > Higgins
which one would you choose?

either trade goodes or miller