Need help Gurus. Plzz rate

Started by Marcos83, March 26, 2015, 09:23:44 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Marcos83

DEF:
Simpson Shaw Lumumba Goodes Henderson Saad (Dalgliesh Hamling)

MID:
GAJ Pendles Selwood Fyfe Kennedy Neale Cripps Ellis-Yol ( Anderson, Vanden, Steele)

RUX:
Leuy Bellchambers (Brooksby)

FWD:
Bartel D.Martin Swan J.Martin/J.Cameron Clark Hogan
(Daniel, Cox)

Not sure if I should get J.Martin or J.Cameron in FWDs. Could downgrade MID premo to balance out the team in DEF and FWD, however not many players I trust with consistency in those ares.

Any thoughts guys will be very appreciated.

Marcos83

43 views and no replies. Ppl coping my team now or is it dreadful that no1 need reply?

RaisyDaisy

Not a bad team man :)

That midfield is super stacked, but obviously you're rucks have taken a big hit

Don't bother with Martin or Cameron. Downgrade that spot to Salem then upgrade one of your rucks

Get rid of Cox at F8 too. Plenty of playing forward rookies to make you cash there

I'm not sold on Henderson at all, but that's just me

Marcos83

Thanks for your comments. Changes have been made. Leaving belly as ruck though as think he will average at least 80. For 300k its a bargain.

Big Mac

Quote from: Marcos83 on March 26, 2015, 10:58:36 PM
Thanks for your comments. Changes have been made. Leaving belly as ruck though as think he will average at least 80. For 300k its a bargain.

That's assuming he even plays

I'd plan for life without Belly first - much easier to put him back in later if he becomes available

Also hasn't played any preseason games so will be very rusty for the first few rounds

crowls

#5
Quote from: Big  Mac on March 26, 2015, 11:33:48 PM
Quote from: Marcos83 on March 26, 2015, 10:58:36 PM
Thanks for your comments. Changes have been made. Leaving belly as ruck though as think he will average at least 80. For 300k its a bargain.

That's assuming he even plays

I'd plan for life without Belly first - much easier to put him back in later if he becomes available

Also hasn't played any preseason games so will be very rusty for the first few rounds

Good feedback from RD and BigMac
Goodes may not be upgraded?  What is your plan?   Oxley?    Personally prefer Neale in Backline instead of simpson.  He will drop value at some stage and be a good upgrade.     
Rucks will be a challenge for you.  Is your strategy to trade if injured or not available.   For me you need one premier ruck.  Goldy probably best option or Maric for a cheaper option.   McEvoy has possibility of improving this year.    Belly may not start due to ADSA and as BM said, will be rusty due to lack of preseason games.   

Summary get cash by downgrading Simpson, Goodes, Martin/Cameron.   Upgrade Rucks.

AaronKirk

I'd downgrade Neale to Newton, Martin/Cameron to Salem and then use the cash to upgrade one ruck to a premo.

If you choose not to upgrade Belly you should have a plan in place to make adjustments and see what it looks like now well before lockout.

Marcos83

DEF
Gibson Shaw Lumumba Newnes Goodes Saad (Oxley Hamling)

MID:
GAJ Pendles  Fyfe Kennedy Ward Cripps Ellis-Yol Vandenberg (Anderson, Miller, Steele)

RUX:
Leuy NicNat (Cox)

FWD:
Gray Bartel D.Martin Bellchambers Clark Hogan
(Daniel, Lambert)

$100 left only

Ok a bit of tinkering since the OP. This side complete for Round1?